Sort:
Open Access Issue
Global impact and contribution of traditional Chinese medicine: a bibliometric analysis based on 98,746 studies
Journal of Beijing University of Traditional Chinese Medicine 2025, 48(12): 1764-1776
Published: 23 October 2025
Abstract PDF (5.4 MB) Collect
Downloads:6
Objective

To analyze the current publication status of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) in international journals and to evaluate its global influence and scholarly contributions within the field.

Methods

A bibliometric approach was employed using VOSviewer 1. 6. 17, CiteSpace 5. 8. R2, and the R Studio Bibliometrix package to conduct a visualized analysis of publications related to TCM research from the PubMed and Web of Science databases from their inception to March 19, 2025. The analysis included the number of papers, citation times, publication time, research institutions, authors, and regional distribution. Additionally, impact factor (IF) of the journal was calculated, and subgroup analyses were conducted based on clinical research and disease categories.

Results

From the inception of the databases until March 19, 2025, a total of 98,746 research articles on TCM have been published, of which 9,575 are clinical research papers, with 7,083 (73.97%) reporting positive outcomes. Over the past two decades, the annual publication volume in TCM research has increased steadily. The research encompasses 217 countries and regions, involving 279,128 authors and 37,662 participating institutions, including internationally renowned academic entities such as Harvard Medical School. A total of 4,598 high-impact scholarly articles (journal IF >10) have been published in the field, of which 172 were clinical studies. Among the TCM clinical research papers that reported positive results, 35 papers were published in authoritative journals with an IF over 40. TCM research has the largest number of publications in the field of oncology, reaching 13,001 articles.

Conclusion

The clinical application value of TCM has gained widespread recognition within the international academic community. Its scientific validity and clinical efficacy have been empirically validated by high-quality research published in authoritative journals. This study provides a significant scholarly foundation for the globalization and scientific evaluation of TCM.

Open Access Issue
Pathogenesis and diagnosis and treatment strategies of multimorbidity of allergic diseases based on traditional Chinese medicine constitution theory
Journal of Beijing University of Traditional Chinese Medicine 2025, 48(11): 1487-1493
Published: 19 September 2025
Abstract PDF (1.3 MB) Collect
Downloads:4

Allergic diseases are one of the major chronic diseases worldwide. Epidemiological studies suggest that the clustering of multiple allergic diseases as multimorbidity within the same individual is a significant phenomenon that cannot be overlooked. Currently, there is a lack of targeted diagnostic and therapeutic guidelines for multimorbidity of allergic diseases, and their pathogenesis remains unclear. Traditional Chinese medicine constitution serves as the foundation for disease development and is a key target for preventing and treating multimorbidity. The inherited special constitution, qi-deficient constitution, and yang-deficient constitution are the primary constitution types associated with multimorbidity of allergic diseases, with the inherited special constitution being the most prevalent. Allergic constitution, a type of the inherited special constitution is a specific constitution formed on the basis of innate inheritance, characterized by heightened sensitivity to multiple allergens. Affected by environmental factors, people with allergic constitution may suffer from different allergic diseases, with specific types of allergic diseases being more prevalent at different stages of life, and they are often accompanied by multimorbidities such as psychological and immunological disorders. This paper proposed an integrated diagnostic and therapeutic model of "constitution differentiation-disease differentiation-syndrome differentiation" comprehensively considering constitution, disease, and syndrome. Combined with regulating constitution formula Guominkang and its modifications, this approach has demonstrated significant efficacy in treating allergic diseases and shows promise for managing multimorbidity of allergic diseases.

Open Access Issue
New strategies for preventing and treating kidney disease with multimorbidity based on the body constitution of traditional Chinese medicine
Journal of Beijing University of Traditional Chinese Medicine 2025, 48(11): 1494-1500
Published: 01 July 2025
Abstract PDF (1.3 MB) Collect
Downloads:0

Multimorbidity is a significant challenge to global public health. In particular, the interaction between metabolic diseases, cardiovascular diseases, and chronic kidney disease further complicates the condition and treatment in patients with kidney diseases. Current strategies for managing multimorbidity often combine treatments for specific diseases passively, which can easily lead to polypharmacy issues. An urgent need exists to break through the theoretical framework of disease-centered medicine, transcend conventional thinking, and explore novel therapeutic strategies. Therefore, this paper proposes that the integration of the kidney zang-xiang theory and the body constitution of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) would be beneficial for handling this problem. Preventive treatment of disease is a unique advantage of TCM, and the body constitution theory and method ology are essential strategies for preventive medicine in TCM. Holistic views guide the entire process of body constitution and preventive treatment of disease. By subdividing different pre-disease states within the full cycle of health and disease and discovering the regularity of cross-organ progression of the disease and its effect on kidney disease under the guidance of "the soil theory of body constitution," modern nephrology findings can be integrated to tailor comprehensive prevention and treatment plans for different pre-disease states, different types of kidney diseases, and their comorbidity models, thereby addressing the issue of kidney disease with multimorbidity.

Open Access Issue
Theoretical innovation and practice of traditional Chinese medicine constitution on the diagnosis and treatment of multimorbidity
Journal of Beijing University of Traditional Chinese Medicine 2025, 48(11): 1481-1486
Published: 24 June 2025
Abstract PDF (1.3 MB) Collect
Downloads:1

Based on the practical problems faced by the current diagnosis and treatment of multimorbidity, this paper systematically summarizes the conceptual category and research status of multimorbidity, as well as the opportunities and challenges of the traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) constitution in handling comorbidity. The constitution of TCM has unique advantages in clarifying the causes of "multi-disease co-occurrence," exploring the essence of "different diseases with the same constitution," and formulating a strategy for the "same prevention and treatment." This paper primarily discusses the practical value of the TCM constitution in the prevention and treatment of multimorbidity from three aspects: constitution identification provides an early warning for the same prevention of different diseases; treatment based on constitution differentiation provides a new way of treating different diseases; and the microscopic mechanism clarifies the scientific basis of the same prevention and treatment strategies. The pathogenesis, prevention, and treatment views of the TCM constitution offer a novel theoretical perspective on the mechanism of multimorbidity occurrence, provide practical directions for the prevention and treatment of multimorbidity, and offer ideas and preliminary exploration for the construction of a diagnosis and treatment system for multimorbidity in cooperation with Chinese and Western medicine.

Open Access Opinion Paper Issue
Expert consensus on the positioning of the “Three-in-One” Registration and Evaluation Evidence System and the value of orientation of the “personal experience”
Evidence-Based Chinese Medicine and Technology Assessment 2025, 1(1): 9570006
Published: 30 April 2025
Abstract PDF (909 KB) Collect
Downloads:150

Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM), as a treasure of the Chinese nation, plays a significant role in maintaining public health. In 2019, the Central Committee of the Communist Party of China and the State Council proposed for the first time the establishment of a TCM registration and evaluation evidence system that integrates TCM theory, personal experience and clinical trials (referred to as the “Three-in-One” System) to promote the inheritance and innovation of TCM. Subsequently, the National Medical Products Administration issued several guiding principles to advance the improvement and implementation of this system. Owing to the complexity of its implementation, there are still differing understandings within the TCM industry regarding the positioning of the “Three-in-One” Registration and Evaluation Evidence System, as well as the connotation and value orientation of the “personal experience.” To address this, Academician Qi Wang, President of the TCM Association, China International Exchange and Promotion Association for Medical and Healthcare and TCM master, led a group of academicians, TCM masters, TCM pharmacology experts and clinical TCM experts to convene a “Seminar on Promoting the Implementation of the ‘Three-in-One’ Registration and Evaluation Evidence System for Chinese Medicinals.” Through extensive discussions, an expert consensus was formed, clarifying the different roles of the TCM theory, “personal experience” and clinical trials within the system. It was further emphasized that the “personal experience” is the core of this system, and its data should be derived from clinical practice scenarios. In the future, the improvement of this system will require collaborative efforts across multiple fields to promote the high-quality development of the Chinese medicinal industry.

Open Access Review Article Issue
Scientific connotation of “treating different diseases with the same method” from the perspective of metabolic–immune dysregulation in inflammation-mediated carcinogenesis of digestive organs
Journal of Traditional Chinese Medical Sciences 2023, 10(1): 3-9
Published: 07 December 2022
Abstract PDF (654.8 KB) Collect
Downloads:17

Inflammation-mediated carcinogenesis develops in the context of chronic inflammation and is a significant cause of cancer within the digestive system. In the chronic inflammation microenvironment, the metabolic activity of tissue cells undergoes extensive changes, which interfere with the normal function of immune cells. Dysregulation of cell metabolism and immune function has been identified as a key factor contributing to inflammation-mediated carcinogenesis within the major digestive organs, such as the stomach, liver, and colorectum. This metabolic–immune imbalance also corresponds to traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) theories of “yin-yang disharmony” and “disharmony between Ying-nutrients and Wei-defense.” The metabolic–immune imbalance has also been regarded as the key factor supporting “treatment of different diseases with the same method,” in which the same approach is adopted in the treatment of different conditions. In the TCM treatment process, it is necessary to first identify TCM patterns and then apply the corresponding TCM to correct the dysregulated metabolic and immune function, thereby blocking the progression from inflammation to malignancy. Our study findings deepen the TCM understanding of metabolic–immune dysregulation and the relationship between metabolic–immune dysregulation, pattern identification, and treatment method. They also provide new insights for the treatment of inflammation-mediated carcinogenesis in major digestive organs and help us further explore the scientific connotation of the TCM strategy of “treating different diseases with the same method.

Open Access Original Article Issue
Association between metabolic syndrome and body constitution of traditional Chinese medicine: A systematic review and meta-analysis
Journal of Traditional Chinese Medical Sciences 2020, 7(4): 355-365
Published: 23 October 2020
Abstract PDF (1.9 MB) Collect
Downloads:29
Background

The constitution theory of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) states that body constitution and disease are associated; therefore, the identification of body constitution can provide reference for disease prevention and treatment. A series of clinical studies evaluating the association between TCM constitution and metabolic syndrome (MetS) have been conducted in recent years. The aim of this systematic review is to summarize and evaluate the clinical evidence of the relationship between constitution and MetS.

Methods

The PubMed, Embase, China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI), Chongqing VIP, and Wanfang Data electronic databases were searched from April 2009 to July 2020. The search terms included "metabolic syndrome, " "constitution, " and "Chinese medicine." Observational studies evaluating the relationship between body constitution of TCM and MetS were included. The primary outcome included the distribution of constitutional types in the MetS population, and odds ratio (OR) or relative risk (RR) between constitution and MetS. Effect size was expressed as proportion or OR with 95% confidence interval (CI). Methodological quality of included studies was evaluated by the Newcastle–Ottawa Scale (NOS) or the American Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) criteria.

Results

Three case–control and 26 cross-sectional studies involving 30435 cases were included. Phlegm-dampness, qi-deficiency, and damp-heat were the main constitution types in patients with MetS, accounting for 29% (22%–39%), 18% (13%–24%), and 12% (9%–17%) of the population, respectively; the risk of MetS in people with phlegm-dampness and qi-deficiency constitution was 1.74 [1.27, 2.38] and 1.29 [1.01, 1.65] times higher than that in those with other constitutions. There were sex- and age-related differences in the distribution of TCM constitution in patients with MetS.

Conclusion

Phlegm-dampness and qi-deficiency were associated with the occurrence of MetS. Well-designed cohort and case–control studies are needed to provide evidence for the use of TCM to prevent and treat MetS.

Open Access Original Article Issue
Characteristics of 240 randomized controlled trials for adjusting constitution in preventive treatment of disease: A bibliometric analysis
Journal of Traditional Chinese Medical Sciences 2019, 6(3): 226-233
Published: 16 August 2019
Abstract PDF (533.6 KB) Collect
Downloads:9
Background

A growing number of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) have explored the significance of adjusting constitution for preventive treatment of disease in traditional Chinese medicine (TCM). In this study, we sought to comprehensively analyze the characteristics of these RCTs.

Methods

All RCTs related to constitutional adjustment and preventive treatment of disease were included in the study. Literature was screened searching seven databases, including Pubmed, Web of Science, Embase, SinoMed, CNKI, Chongqing VIP, and Wangfang Database, from inception to December 2018. Data pertaining to bibliometrics, participants, and interventions were extracted and analyzed.

Results

Two hundred and forty papers were published between 2007 and 2018, involving 240 RCTs with 55977 total participants. Sample size in these RCTs ranged from 30 to 7800. Among them, 59 RCTs addressed disease prevention prior to onset involving 11 healthy states of participants, mainly for general health or sub-health population (40.68%) using health care and non-drug therapy. In control the development of existing disease (n = 174), 59 diseases were involved. Based on the number of RCTs and sample sizes, diseases including type 2 diabetes mellitus, primary hypertension, nonalcoholic fatty liver disease, and hyperlipoproteinemia accounted for 51.15% of the total patients studied. Drug therapy as an intervention was frequently used. In preventing recurrence after recovery (n = 7), over 4 kinds of health status in participants were involved. Drug therapy combined with health care was mostly used. Most RCTs reported positive outcomes, with only one reporting negative findings (1/240).

Conclusion

The number of RCTs of constitutional adjustment on preventive treatment of disease has gradually increased since 2012. Participants and intervention measures from the above-mentioned types of RCTs exhibit their own characteristics. Future systematic reviews or meta-analyses on constitutional adjustment for preventive treatment of disease are warranted.

Open Access Original Article Issue
Correlation between Tibetan and traditional Chinese medicine body constitutions: A cross-sectional study of Tibetan college students in the Tibet Autonomous Region
Journal of Traditional Chinese Medical Sciences 2018, 5(3): 215-221
Published: 08 November 2018
Abstract PDF (402.8 KB) Collect
Downloads:14
Objective

To evaluate the correlation between the body constitution types of Tibetan medicine and traditional Chinese medicine (TCM).

Methods

The cluster sampling method was employed to recruit participants from a university in the Tibet Autonomous Region. Tibetan medicine and TCM questionnaires were respectively used to assess the participants' constitution information. Descriptive statistics were applied to analyze the baseline and constitution characteristics of the participants. Two-factor correlation analysis and the paired chi-square test were applied to analyze the correlation between Tibetan and TCM constitution types.

Results

Data from 466 Tibetan students were analyzed. The mean scores of the rlung, mkhris pa, and bad kan constitution types in Tibetan medicine were 43.2 (11.1), 42.1 (10.1), and 45.0 (8.0), respectively; participants with the three-factor convergence body constitution type accounted for 13.7% of the whole population. Among the TCM constitution types, qi stagnation was the most common (21.5%), followed by the balance type (16.5%); the other constitutions detected were qi deficiency, yin deficiency, and yang deficiency. The rate of consistency for the identification of the three-factor convergence constitution in Tibetan medicine and the balance constitution in TCM was 89.1%, with a Kappa coefficient of 0.57 (P > .05). The rlung constitution in Tibetan medicine was associated with the yin deficiency, yang deficiency, and blood stasis constitutions in TCM. The mkhris pa constitution in Tibetan medicine was associated with the damp heat and yin deficiency constitutions in TCM. The bad kan constitution in Tibetan medicine was associated with the phlegm dampness, qi deficiency, and yin deficiency constitutions in TCM.

Conclusion

There is a correlation between the body constitution types of Tibetan medicine and TCM. The reliability and validity of the Questionnaire for Tibetan Medicine Constitution requires improvement, and more studies with larger sample sizes and more varied populations are warranted to verify the correlation between Tibetan medicine and TCM constitutions.

Open Access Original Article Issue
Association between body-constitution type and vascular endothelial dysfunction: A cross-sectional study in an adult obese/overweight population
Journal of Traditional Chinese Medical Sciences 2018, 5(2): 94-99
Published: 25 May 2018
Abstract PDF (397.5 KB) Collect
Downloads:7
Objective

To measure vascular endothelial function (VED) in obese/overweight people grouped according to the constitutional theory of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM). We wished to predict the risk of VED and cardiovascular diseases in obese/overweight populations.

Methods

This was a cross-sectional study. Eighty-six obese/overweight volunteers from Beijing Chao-Yang Hospital were enrolled and divided into four groups based on body-constitution type: phlegm dampness (PD); phlegm dampness with blood stasis (PDBS); qi-deficiency (QD); balance (BA). Height, weight, waist circumference and hip circumference were measured, and percent body fat and reactive hyperemia index (RHI) calculated. Levels of vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF), von Willebrand factor (vWF) and plasma endothelial-1 (ET-1) were detected by immunohistochemistry.

Results

The RHI and vWF levels in the PDBS group were significantly lower than those in the BA group and QD group (P < .05), but there was no significant difference compared with the PD group (P > .05). These two indicators displayed no significant differences among BA, QD, and PD groups (P > .05). There was no significant difference among the four groups in level of ET-1 or VEGF (P > .05).

Conclusion

Of the four indicators selected, the RHI and vWF displayed significant differences between the PDBS group and BA group, and between the PDBS group and QD group. Hence, in an obese/overweight population with different constitutional types, compared with BA and QD groups, a relatively higher risk of suffering from VED was detected in the PDBS group. Meanwhile, this study provides the experimental basis for confirming the feasibility of constitutional classification in obese/overweight population.

Total 14