After carbon dioxide, methane is a greenhouse gas that has the greatest impact on global warming. Methane produced through ruminal fermentation in ruminants not only contributes substantially to greenhouse gas emissions from the livestock sector, but also represents a loss of dietary energy, thereby reducing feed energy utilization efficiency and animal productivity. Therefore, elucidating the regulatory mechanisms underlying ruminal methane production and emission and establishing scientific, standardized mitigation assessment methods applicable to different production systems are of considerable importance for promoting the green and low-carbon development of the livestock industry and achieving the “Dual Carbon” goals. This paper systematically reviewed recent advances in the mechanisms and detection methods associated with methane mitigation in ruminants. First, according to the processes involved in ruminal methanogenesis and their regulatory points, methane inhibitors were classified into feed additives that regulated volatile fatty acid production and reduced hydrogen accumulation, inhibitors targeting methanogens and their key enzymes, and substances that promoted methane oxidation. The methane mitigation effects of 3-nitrooxypropanol (3-NOP), seaweed, nitrate, essential oils, tannins, lipids and combined additives were summarized, with particular emphasis on their effects on feed intake, average daily gain, milk yield and methane emission intensity in ruminants. Secondly, the effects of different physiological stages, dietary compositions, production systems and experimental durations on the assessment of mitigation efficacy were discussed in relation to Latin-square, crossover and continuous experimental designs. The importance of combining short-term trials with long-term monitoring was also emphasized. Thirdly, research approaches for elucidating the mechanisms of action of methane inhibitors were systematically reviewed from the perspectives of microbiology, cellular and molecular biology, ruminal fermentation and ecosystem functioning, animal metabolism, and integrated multidisciplinary research. These mechanisms included the regulation of methanogen communities, inhibition of methyl-coenzyme M reductase and coenzyme M methyltransferase activities, modification of hydrogen metabolism and volatile fatty acid production, alteration of electron acceptor utilization, and promotion of methane oxidation. In addition, this paper compared empirical screening with target-based design strategies for discovering bioactive substances, and introduced technologies including high-throughput screening, isolation and purification, structural identification using mass spectrometry and nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, molecular docking and computational modelling. With regard to methane emission measurements, the principles, application conditions, advantages and limitations of respiration chambers, the sulphur hexafluoride tracer technique, the GreenFeed system, face masks, portable accumulation chambers, house-flux methods, open-path laser detection, unmanned aerial vehicles and satellite remote sensing were reviewed. The selection of an appropriate detection method should be based on the research objectives, animal production system, available equipment and the required measurement accuracy. Finally, the applications of empirical, mechanistic and machine-learning models in predicting methane emissions and mitigation potential were summarized. The need to strengthen the integration of high-quality data, standardize additive dosage and delivery methods, assess both short-term effects and long-term adaptation, and conduct integrated evaluations of mitigation efficacy, animal performance, product safety and life-cycle environmental impacts was highlighted. This review provided a theoretical basis and technical reference for the screening of methane inhibitors in ruminants, elucidation of their mechanisms of action, experimental design, methane emission measurement and prediction of mitigation potential.
- Article type
- Year
- Co-author
Methane (CH4) is the second most significant greenhouse gas globally, yet due to its potent short-term warming effect, it has a pronounced impact on near-term global climate warming. In recent years, atmospheric CH4 concentrations have continued to rise, reaching 1.6 times pre-industrial levels by 2024. CH4 emissions contribute to global warming, threatening human living environments and health, with the social cost of each ton of CH4 emissions amounting to thousands of dollars. Ruminants represent one of the primary anthropogenic sources of CH4 emissions in the agricultural sector, making their CH4 mitigation crucial. The CH4 emitted by ruminants is predominantly generated by rumen microorganisms through hydrogenotrophic, methylotrophic, and acetate-cleavage pathways, with the hydrogenotrophic pathway, where hydrogen (H2) reduces carbon dioxide (CO2) to form CH4, which dominates the process. Consequently, H2 serves as a critical precursor in rumen CH4 production, and appropriately reducing or consuming H2 production during rumen microbial fermentation represents the most direct strategy for CH4 mitigation. H2 is produced by various H2-producing microorganisms (protozoa, bacteria, and fungi), with protozoa primarily consisting of holotrichs, bacteria dominated by Clostridia within the Firmicutes phylum, and certain fungi also capable of H2 production. Protozoa, bacteria, and fungi generate H2 during the fermentation of rumen carbohydrates to produce volatile fatty acids. The H2-producing capacities vary among different H2-producing microorganisms. Specifically, the H2-producing ability of protozoa is related to factors, such as body length and the number of hydrogenosomes, with holotrich protozoa and large protozoa being high-H2-producing groups. For bacteria, their H2-producing capacity is associated with the H2-producing pathways they mediate, with acetate-and H2-producing bacteria showing relatively high H2-producing abilities. There are relatively few reports on fungi. The aforementioned high-H2-producing microorganisms can serve as important targets for reducing the transfer of H2 to methanogenic pathways and promoting CH4 mitigation. Although there are differences in the H2-producing capacities of various H2-producing microorganisms, most of their H2-producing pathways require the participation of hydrogenases. Hydrogenases can utilize reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NADH) and reduced ferredoxin (Fdred) generated during rumen fermentation to reduce H+ and produce H2. In addition, the H2-producing pathways of H2-producing microorganisms are influenced by the composition of the microbial community, the nutritional structure of the diet, and functional additives. These factors affect H2 production efficiency by regulating the rumen H2-producing fermentation pattern, hydrogen partial pressure, and the expression of hydrogenase in vivo, as well as the activity of H2-producing microorganisms. Based on these hydrogen production characteristics, H2 production by H2-producing microorganisms can be reduced to promote CH4 mitigation: the community composition of rumen H2-producing microorganisms can be optimized to promote low-H2-producing microorganisms dominating rumen fermentation, such as feeding Bacillus subtilis; the expression of hydrogenase in H2-producing microorganisms can also be regulated, for example, through dietary nutrient regulation; additionally, the activity of H2-producing microorganisms can be directly inhibited, such as by adding plant extracts like tannins or traditional Chinese medicine formulas to the diet. This review summarized the types and characteristics of H2-producing microorganisms in the rumen, providing a theoretical basis for developing CH4 mitigation strategies at the source.
京公网安备11010802044758号