With the implementation of the European Union's new battery regulation mandating the circular footprint formula (CFF) to facilitate battery recycling, there is a need to re-evaluate end-of-life (EoL) strategies for retired batteries. This study conducts a comprehensive environmental and economic comparison of five EoL scenarios under the CFF framework, namely, baseline (BAU), original equipment manufacturer-led collection (OEM), pyrometallurgical route (PYRO), bioleaching route (BIO), and enhanced cascade utilization (ECU-20), in which key dimensions of recycling technologies, cascade utilization rates, and collection models are compared with case of NCM811 battery. Compared with BAU, our results indicate that ECU-20 is the most effective strategy, with a 15.90% reduction in the carbon footprint and a 57.3% increase in the economic benefit. Meanwhile, BIO delivers remarkable performance with an 8.29% carbon footprint reduction and 17.5% economic gain, while OEM scenario achieves a modest 1.43% carbon footprint reduction and slight economic optimization. Among those, PYRO performs the worst, with an 8.46% higher carbon footprint and 24.7% lower economic benefit due to poor metal recovery rates. This research provides a comprehensive CFF-compliant quantitative basis for stakeholders to adapt to international regulations and design sustainable battery value chains.
Publications
- Article type
- Year
- Co-author
Article type
Year
Open Access
Original Research
Issue
Circular Economy 2026, 5(4): 100224
Published: 23 September 2026
Downloads:0
Total 1
京公网安备11010802044758号