The study of time-fractional problems with derivatives in terms of Caputo is a recent area of study in biological models. In this article, fractional differential equations with phytoplankton-toxic phytoplankton-zooplankton (PTPZ) system were solved using the Laplace transform method (LTM), the Adomain decomposition method (ADM), and the differential transform method (DTM). This study demonstrates the good agreement between the results produced by using the specified computational techniques. The numerical results displayed as graphs demonstrate the accuracy of the computational methods. The approaches that have been established are thus quite relevant and suitable for solving nonlinear fractional models. Meanwhile, the impact of changing the fractional order of a time derivative and time $t$ on populations of phytoplankton, toxic-phytoplankton, and zooplankton has been examined using graphical representations. Furthermore, the stability analysis of the LTM approach has been discussed.