Publications
Sort:
Open Access Research Article Issue
Near-Term NASA Mars and Lunar In Situ Propellant Production: Complexity versus Simplicity
Space: Science & Technology 2024, 4: 0188
Published: 02 August 2024
Abstract PDF (2.2 MB) Collect
Downloads:0

Martian in situ propellant production (ISPP) has a fundamental advantage over lunar ISPP because it has much greater leverage. The value of Martian ISPP per liftoff far exceeds that for the lunar ISPP. This study analyzes the challenges and complexity of lunar ISPP versus Mars ISPP and finds that lunar ISPP is so challenging it might not even be feasible, and if it is feasible, the payoff appears to be limited, while the investment is likely to be great. By contrast, Mars ISPP based on atmosphere only is relatively simple with high payoff. NASA is heavily focused on lunar ISPP and seemingly has diminished interest in solid oxide electrolysis of Martian CO2 to O2 after an extremely successful demonstration on Mars by MOXIE. This might make sense at first glance, but when the 2 leading candidates for lunar ISPP are analyzed in detail, it is found that they are extremely difficult and challenging to implement, the effort and investment involved in developing and implementing them are high, and the potential payoff is limited. By contrast, Mars ISPP by solid oxide electrolysis cell (SOEC) of CO2 is comparatively simple and reliable and has high payoff. A SOEC system is basically landed, and a switch is turned on. The only feedstock is the ubiquitous atmosphere. Lunar ISPP involves a seemingly endless number of complex dynamic steps including autonomous traverses of excavator/haulers to unearth (unmoon?) regolith and deliver it to and from a reactor.

Open Access Research Article Issue
Adapting a Mars ISRU System to the Changing Mars Environment
Space: Science & Technology 2023, 3: 0041
Published: 09 June 2023
Abstract PDF (1.9 MB) Collect
Downloads:15

This study modeled the performance of a full-scale Mars in situ resource utilization (ISRU) system to produce 30 metric tons of liquid O2, operated for 14 months at half-hourly intervals as the Mars environment changes diurnally and seasonally. We considered various control options, with particular emphasis on power requirements and required cell voltages. Mars temperature and pressure data at half-hour intervals were obtained from the Mars Perseverance team. The full-scale Mars ISRU system included a mechanical compressor, high-temperature electrolysis of Martian CO2, and a liquefier to produce liquid oxygen. The key factors were (a) maintaining cell voltage well below the Nernst potential for carbon formation from CO and (b) tracking the maximum power, as well as the range of power required, at each half-hourly junction across the 14-month run for each control option. The most favorable control option involved adjusting the compressor revolutions per minute at each half-hour to produce a quasi-steady state of oxygen production in the electrolysis and the liquefaction systems, resulting in the most benign electrolysis settings, the lowest maximum power, and the narrowest range of required power. Other approaches where the compressor was run at a steady state and the oxygen production rate varied with time led to higher electrolysis voltage, higher maximum power, and a wider range of power. This study provides guidance on the optimum operating conditions and power requirements of a Mars ISRU system to produce 30 metric tons of liquid oxygen in 14 months of operation.

Total 2