Maintaining soil fertility through balanced fertilization is essential for ensuring high crop productivity in intensive paddy–upland rotation systems. In this study, a meta-analysis of 141 published studies was conducted to evaluate the effects of different fertilization regimes on soil chemical properties and crop yields in predominant paddy–upland rotation systems. Relative to balanced fertilization (BF), both no fertilization (CK) and unbalanced fertilization (UF) significantly reduced soil organic matter (SOM) (16.6% and 7.2%), total N (11.3% and 4.9%), total P (14.6% and 7.1%), available P (41.0% and 22.9%), and available K (13.0% and 11.0%). In contrast, the combined application of chemical fertilizer with organic manure (F+M) or straw return (F+S) significantly increased SOM (16.5% and 9.6%), total N (14.9% and 8.7%), total P (29.2% and 16.6%), available P (37.6% and14.7%), and available K (9.1% and 12.9%). Notably, the response of soil fertility to fertilization regimes differed between oilseed rape–rice (OR) and wheat–rice (WR) rotations. The WR rotation showed greater declines in SOM and total N under CK treatment than the OR rotation. While F+S treatment was more effective in improving soil available P in OR rotation, F+M treatment produced better outcomes in WR rotation. These soil responses were reflected in crop yields, with a more severe rice yield reduction under CK in the WR (45.0%) than in the OR rotation (29.2%). The greatest yield increases were associated with the F+S treatment in OR and the F+M treatment in WR. Random Forest analysis and linear regression identified SOM, available P, and total N as the primary factors governing rice yield. These results suggest that integrated nutrient management combining chemical fertilizers with organic amendments is crucial for sustaining soil fertility and productivity in paddy–upland rotations, and that tailored fertilization strategies should be developed based on specific rice-based cropping systems.
- Article type
- Year
- Co-author
Open Access
Research Article
Issue
The application of chemical fertilizers and organic materials is a crucial measure for increasing agricultural production. Rice-rapeseed rotation system is a primary paddy-upland crop rotation pattern in the Yangtze River basin of China. Clarifying the impact of chemical fertilizers and organic material inputs on the annual crop yield and nutrient utilization in rice-rapeseed rotation could provide a scientific basis for ensuring food and oil security and achieving green and sustainable agricultural development.
From 2017 to 2022, a continuous field experiment was conducted at the Huazhong Agricultural University's Shayang Experimental Station in Shayang County, Hubei Province. Four treatments were established: no fertilizer (CK), chemical fertilizer only (NPK), chemical fertilizer with straw return (NPK+S), and chemical fertilizer with straw return plus organic fertilizer (NPK+S+M). The crop yields, nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P) and potassium (K) nutrient absorption of rapeseed and rice were analyzed. The nutrient use efficiency, apparent nutrient balances, and their relationships with yield were also assessed.
The average results over 6 years showed that compared with no fertilization, the application of chemical fertilizers and organic materials significantly increased the yield of rapeseed (493.5%-758.8%) and rice (94.3%-106.4%), and enhanced crop yield stability (24.6%-72.1%) and sustainability (17.2%-85.0%). Compared with the NPK treatment, the NPK+S treatment increased the yield of rapeseed by 6.3%, but decreased yield stability and sustainability; it decreased the yield of rice by 0.8%, but increased yield stability and sustainability. The NPK+S+M treatment increased the yield of rapeseed and rice by 44.7% and 5.4%, respectively, and improved the sustainability of yield. Throughout the rotation cycle, nutrient uptake by rapeseed was consistently lower than that by rice across all treatments. The addition of organic materials significantly enhanced nutrient uptake in both rapeseed and rice. Relative to the NPK treatment, the NPK+S+M treatment resulted in increases of 5.1%-91.2% in average nutrient uptake and 12.2%-100.4% in trend nutrient uptake. The NPK+S treatment did not significantly differ from the NPK treatment in average nutrient uptake but exhibited a 7.7%-25.4% higher trend nutrient uptake. The input of organic materials decreased the physiological nutrient use efficiency of rapeseed and rice. Compared with the NPK treatment, the physiological N use efficiency of rapeseed and rice in the NPK+S+M treatment decreased by 3.0 and 3.7 percentage points, respectively, and the physiological P use efficiency decreased by 19.3 and 25.5 percentage points, respectively. Further analysis revealed that the application of organic materials led to higher apparent nutrient surpluses, which caused the annual increase in the cumulative yield of crops in the rice-rapeseed rotation. The cumulative apparent nutrient surplus was significantly positively correlated with the cumulative crop yield.
The application of chemical fertilizers and organic materials significantly increased crop yields and nutrient use efficiency, and its effects were jointly influenced by crop and nutrient type. Increasing organic fertilization along with chemical fertilizers and straw application could further enhance soil fertility and increase crop yield; however, efforts should focus on improving the physiological nutrient use efficiency to fully realize the potential of organic amendments for sustainable grain and oil production.
By studying the effects of nitrogen fertilizer application rates on the annual crop yields, stability, and nitrogen uptake in the rice-rapeseed rotation system, this study explored the changing trends of the appropriate annual nitrogen fertilizer application rates for rice and rapeseed, so as to provide a theoretical basis for rational fertilization in the rice-rapeseed rotation in the middle reaches of the Yangtze River region.
This locational trial was located in Wuxue City, Hubei Province, and was started in 2016. In this study, eight consecutive years of field locational trials were selected from 2016 to 2024. Five nitrogen fertilizer application rate gradients of 0, 90, 180, 270, and 360 kg N·hm-2 were set up for both crops in the two seasons. The yields and their stability, nitrogen accumulation amounts, nitrogen fertilizer use efficiency, apparent nitrogen surplus, and the annual trends of appropriate nitrogen fertilizer application rates in the rice-rapeseed rotation system were analyzed.
Nitrogen fertilization significantly enhanced crop productivity in rice-rapeseed rotation systems. Compared with the nitrogen-free treatment, in each nitrogen-applied treatment, the average annual yield of rice increased by 1 035-1 769 kg·hm-2, with an increase range of 19.4%-33.2%. The application of nitrogen fertilizer had a significant yield-increasing effect on winter rape; compared with the nitrogen-free treatment, the average annual winter rape yield increased by 1 041-2 208 kg·hm-2, and the yield increased by 1.3-2.8 times. Aboveground nitrogen accumulation in rice and rapeseed increased progressively with elevated N inputs, averaging 36.8-108.2 kg·hm-2 and 43.4-139.3 kg·hm-2 higher than that under the zero-N control, respectively. Continuous observations indicated rising trends in both N accumulation and N recovery efficiency (NRE) for both crops under continuous rotation. During the rice season, with the increase in nitrogen fertilizer application rate, compared with the previous year, the average annual increase in nitrogen accumulation increased from 2.6% to 9.8%. In the rapeseed season, the increase in nitrogen accumulation in the nitrogen-free treatment was not significant among years. After applying nitrogen fertilizer, the nitrogen accumulation increased by an average of 3.4%-5.1% annually compared with the previous year. NRE in rice remained stable during the first three years but exhibited a parabolic rise starting from the fourth year. For rapeseed, NRE under 90-270 kg N·hm-2 N rates increased by 5.6% annually, whereas no significant improvement occurred at 360 kg N·hm-2. Apparent N balance in the zero-N treatment consistently showed deficits, while N-surplus in fertilized plots declined annually by 3.6%-8.3% (rice) and 2.4%-6.7% (rapeseed). Systematic analysis revealed an annual increase of 2.3% in optimal N rates for rice (annual mean: 146.8 kg N·hm-2) and 0.9% for rapeseed (annual mean: 198.0 kg N·hm-2).
In the continuous rice-rapeseed rotation planting mode, it was necessary to apply fertilizers with appropriate nitrogen application rates according to the nitrogen absorption characteristics of the crops in the rotation system, and to dynamically adjust the annual nitrogen allocation amount according to the soil nitrogen status.
Open Access
Research Article
Issue
Chlorosis at leaf margins is a typical symptom of potassium (K) deficiency, but inappropriate application of K with other nutrients often masks symptoms of K deficiency. A two-year field experiment was conducted to measure the interactive effects of N and K on leaf photosynthesis and dry matter accumulation and the resulting growth dilution effect on K concentration and leaf K deficiency symptoms. N application aggravated the imbalance of N and K nutrients and further exacerbated K deficiency symptoms under K limitation. Synergistic effects of N and K promoted plant growth, amplified the growth dilution effect, and reduced the critical K concentration in leaves. Using 90% of the maximum shoot biomass as a threshold, the critical K concentration was 0.72% at the recommended N (N180) fertilization level. The critical K concentration increased by 62.5% owing to the reduced biomass under insufficient N (N90) supply. In contrast, high N (N270) reduced the critical K concentration (0.64%), accelerating chlorophyll decomposition and exacerbating K deficiency symptoms. The basis of changing the critical K concentration by magnifying growth dilution effect was the functional synergistic effect of N and K on photosynthetic characteristics. Under insufficient N, the low maximum carboxylation rate (Vcmax) limited the net photosynthetic rate (An) and necessitated more K to maintain high CO2 transmission capacity, to improve the total conductance gtot /Vcmax ratio. High N supply increased gtot and Vcmax, possibly mitigating the effect of K reduction on photosynthesis. In conclusion, it is unwise to judge K status of plants only by K concentration without accounting for crop mass (or dilution effect), critical K concentration and deficiency symptoms are affected by N fertilization, and the synergistic effect of N and K on leaf photosynthesis is the foundation of maximal growth of plants under diverse critical K concentrations.
京公网安备11010802044758号