Journal Home > Volume 14 , Issue 3

A large amount of heat is needed to maintain the thermal comfort of both indoor and outdoor swimming pools in cold seasons. This motivates the development of various heating technologies aiming to reduce energy use, as well as operating and investment costs. Although their development can be traced back to the 1960s, a comprehensive review of these technologies is lacking. Therefore, this paper presents a comprehensive review of the development of heating technologies for swimming pools. This review firstly introduces available heat transfer models that can be used to calculate or predict heat loss and heat gain for swimming pools. Then, different passive and active technologies are summarized. The active heating technologies used for indoor swimming pools include solar collector, heat pump, waste heat recovery, geothermal energy, and congregation technologies. The active heating technologies used for outdoor swimming pools include solar collector, heat pump, PCM storage, geothermal energy, biomass heater, and waste heat recovery technologies. A discussion is presented on the practical and possible heating techniques for swimming pool applications. Finally, through the reviewed literature, future research opportunities are identified, to guide researchers to investigate swimming pool heating systems with suitable and relevant technologies.


menu
Abstract
Full text
Outline
About this article

Swimming pool heating technology: A state-of-the-art review

Show Author's information Yantong Li1,2( )Natasa Nord2Gongsheng Huang1Xin Li1
Department of Architecture and Civil Engineering, City University of Hong Kong, Tat Chee Avenue, Kowloon, Hong Kong, China
Department of Energy and Process Engineering, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Trondheim, Norway

Abstract

A large amount of heat is needed to maintain the thermal comfort of both indoor and outdoor swimming pools in cold seasons. This motivates the development of various heating technologies aiming to reduce energy use, as well as operating and investment costs. Although their development can be traced back to the 1960s, a comprehensive review of these technologies is lacking. Therefore, this paper presents a comprehensive review of the development of heating technologies for swimming pools. This review firstly introduces available heat transfer models that can be used to calculate or predict heat loss and heat gain for swimming pools. Then, different passive and active technologies are summarized. The active heating technologies used for indoor swimming pools include solar collector, heat pump, waste heat recovery, geothermal energy, and congregation technologies. The active heating technologies used for outdoor swimming pools include solar collector, heat pump, PCM storage, geothermal energy, biomass heater, and waste heat recovery technologies. A discussion is presented on the practical and possible heating techniques for swimming pool applications. Finally, through the reviewed literature, future research opportunities are identified, to guide researchers to investigate swimming pool heating systems with suitable and relevant technologies.

Keywords: phase change material, heat pump, solar energy, swimming pool, heating supply

References(127)

Abdel-Khalik SI (1976). Heat removal factor for a flat-plate solar collector with a serpentine tube. Solar Energy, 18: 59-64.
Aketouane Z, Malha M, Bruneau D, Bah A, Michel B, Asbik M, Ansari O (2018). Energy savings potential by integrating Phase Change Material into hollow bricks: The case of Moroccan buildings. Building Simulation, 11: 1109-1122.
Alkhamis A, Sherif S (1992). Performance analysis of a solar-assisted swimming pool heating system. Energy, 17: 1165-1172.
Amin ZM, Hawlader MNA (2013). A review on solar assisted heat pump systems in Singapore. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 26: 286-293.
Argyrou MC, Christodoulides P, Kalogirou SA (2018). Energy storage for electricity generation and related processes: Technologies appraisal and grid scale applications. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 94: 804-821.
ASHRAE (2003). ASHRAE Handbook: HVAC Applications. Atlanta: American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers.
Asdrubali F (2009). A scale model to evaluate water evaporation from indoor swimming pools. Energy and Buildings, 41: 311-319.
Bai Y, Chow T-T, Ménézo C, Dupeyrat P (2012). Analysis of a hybrid PV/thermal solar-assisted heat pump system for sports center water heating application. International Journal of Photoenergy, 2012: 1-13.
Bajwa DS, Peterson T, Sharma N, Shojaeiarani J, Bajwa SG (2018). A review of densified solid biomass for energy production. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 96: 296-305.
Barbato M, Cirillo L, Menditto L, Moretti R, Nardini S (2018). Feasibility study of a geothermal energy system for indoor swimming pool in Campi Flegrei area. Thermal Science and Engineering Progress, 6: 421-425.
Bazilian MD, Leenders F, van der Ree B, Prasad D (2001). Photovoltaic cogeneration in the built environment. Solar Energy, 71: 57-69.
Berardi U, Soudian S (2018). Benefits of latent thermal energy storage in the retrofit of Canadian high-rise residential buildings. Building Simulation, 11: 709-723.
Bergman TL, Incropera FP, DeWitt DP, Lavine AS (2011). Fundamentals of Heat and Mass Transfer, 7th edn. Hoboken, NJ, USA: John Wiley & Sons.
Blázquez JLF, Maestre IR, Gallero FJG, Gómez PÁ (2017). A new practical CFD-based methodology to calculate the evaporation rate in indoor swimming pools. Energy and Buildings, 149: 133-141.
Blázquez JLF, Maestre IR, González Gallero FJ, Álvarez Gómez P (2018). Experimental test for the estimation of the evaporation rate in indoor swimming pools: Validation of a new CFD-based simulation methodology. Building and Environment, 138: 293-299.
Borge D, Colmenar A, Castro M, Martín S, Sancristobal E (2011). Exergy efficiency analysis in buildings climatized with LiCl-H2O solar cooling systems that use swimming pools as heat sinks. Energy and Buildings, 43: 3161-3172.
Bourne S, Novoselac A (2015). Compact PCM-based thermal stores for shifting peak cooling loads. Building Simulation, 8: 673-688.
Bowen IS (1926). The ratio of heat losses by conduction and by evaporation from any water surface. Physical Review, 27: 779.
Brambley MR, Wells SE (1983). Energy-conservation measures for indoor swimming pools. Energy, 8: 403-418.
Brook F (1955). Solar Energy Research. Daniels F, Duffle JA (eds). Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.
Buonomano A, de Luca G, Figaj RD, Vanoli L (2015). Dynamic simulation and thermo-economic analysis of a PhotoVoltaic/ Thermal collector heating system for an indoor-outdoor swimming pool. Energy Conversion and Management, 99: 176-192.
Chan WW, Lam JC (2003). Energy-saving supporting tourism sustainability: A case study of hotel swimming pool heat pump. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 11: 74-83.
Chow TT, Bai Y, Fong KF, Lin Z (2012). Analysis of a solar assisted heat pump system for indoor swimming pool water and space heating. Applied Energy, 100: 309-317.
Ciuman P, Lipska B (2018). Experimental validation of the numerical model of air, heat and moisture flow in an indoor swimming pool. Building and Environment, 145: 1-13.
Clot MR, Rosa-Clot P, Tina GM (2017). Submerged PV solar panel for swimming pools: SP3. Energy Procedia, 134: 567-576.
Croy R, Peuser FA (1994). Experience with solar systems for heating swimming pools in Germany. Solar Energy, 53: 47-52.
Cunio LN, Sproul AB (2012). Performance characterisation and energy savings of uncovered swimming pool solar collectors under reduced flow rate conditions. Solar Energy, 86: 1511-1517.
Czarnecki JT (1963). A method of heating swimming pools by solar energy. Solar Energy, 7: 3-7.
Dang A (1986). A parametric study of swimming pool heating—I. Energy Conversion and Management, 26: 27-31.
Degaulle (2020a). A project for a Vietnam hotel. Available at https:// www.degaullepool.com/vietnam-hotel-swimming-pool-project.html.
Degaulle (2020b). A project for an Indonesia hotel. Available at https://www.degaullepool.com/indonesia-hotel-swimming-pool-project.html.
Delmastro C, Mutani G, Schranz L (2015). Advantages of coupling a woody biomass cogeneration plant with a district heating network for a sustainable built environment: A case study in luserna San Giovanni (Torino, Italy). Energy Procedia, 78: 794-799.
Drissi Lamrhari E-H, Benhamou B (2018). Thermal behavior and energy saving analysis of a flat with different energy efficiency measures in six climates. Building Simulation, 11: 1123-1144.
Du Y, Mak CM, Liu J, Xia Q, Niu J, Kwok KCS (2017). Effects of lift-up design on pedestrian level wind comfort in different building configurations under three wind directions. Building and Environment, 117: 84-99.
Du Y, Mak CM, Ai Z (2018). Modelling of pedestrian level wind environment on a high-quality mesh: A case study for the HKPolyU campus. Environmental Modelling & Software, 103: 105-119.
Du R, Li W, Xiong T, Yang X, Wang Y, Shah KW (2019). Numerical investigation on the melting of nanoparticle-enhanced PCM in latent heat energy storage unit with spiral coil heat exchanger. Building Simulation, 12: 869-879.
Du Y, Blocken B, Pirker S (2020). A novel approach to simulate pollutant dispersion in the built environment: Transport-based recurrence CFD. Building and Environment, 170: 106604.
EU (2020). EU 2030 climate & energy framework. Available at https://ec.europa.eu/clima/policies/strategies/2030_en.
Facão, J, Oliveira AC (2006). Analysis of a micro-cogeneration system using hybrid solar/gas collectors. International Journal of Low-Carbon Technologies, 1: 285-297.
Feng X, Yan D, Yu R, Gao Y (2017). Investigation and modelling of the centralized solar domestic hot water system in residential buildings. Building Simulation, 10: 87-96.
Francey JLA, Golding P, Clarke R (1980). Low-cost solar heating of community pools using pool covers. Solar Energy, 25: 407-416.
Furukakoi M, Adewuyi OB, Matayoshi H, Howlader AM, Senjyu T (2018). Multi objective unit commitment with voltage stability and PV uncertainty. Applied Energy, 228: 618-623.
Gorzin M, Hosseini MJ, Ranjbar AA, Bahrampoury R (2018). Investigation of PCM charging for the energy saving of domestic hot water system. Applied Thermal Engineering, 137: 659-668.
Govaer D, Zarmi Y (1981). Analytical evaluation of direct solar heating of swimming pools. Solar Energy, 27: 529-533.
Govaer D (1984). Determining the solar heating of swimming pools by the utilizability method. Solar Energy, 32: 667-669.
Greyvenstein GP, Meyer JP (1991). The viability of heat pumps for the heating of swimming pools in South Africa. Energy, 16: 1031-1037.
Haaf W, Luboschik U, Tesche B (1994). Solar swimming pool heating: Description of a validated model. Solar Energy, 53: 41-46.
Hahne E, Kübler R (1994). Monitoring and simulation of the thermal performance of solar heated outdoor swimming pools. Solar Energy, 53: 9-19.
Hanssen S, Mathisen H (1990). Evaporation from swimming pools. In: Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Engineering Aero-and Thermodynamics of Ventilated Rooms (Roomvent’90), Oslo, Norway.
Harkouss F, Fardoun F, Biwole PH (2018). Optimization approaches and climates investigations in NZEB—A review. Building Simulation, 11: 923-952.
Harrington C, Modera M (2013). Swimming pools as heat sinks for air conditioners: California feasibility analysis. Energy and Buildings, 59: 252-264.
Holmen (2020). Holmen indoor Swimming Pool, Asker. Available at https://www.arkitektur.no/holmen-indoor-swimming-pool-asker?lcid=1033.
Hong T, Langevin J, Sun K (2018). Building simulation: Ten challenges. Building Simulation, 11: 871-898.
Hou J, Cao M, Liu P (2018). Development and utilization of geothermal energy in China: Current practices and future strategies. Renewable Energy, 125: 401-412.
ISO/TC 180 (1995). ISO/TC 180/SC 4 N 140. Solar Energy—Heating Systems for Swimming Pools—Design and Installation.
Johansson L, Westerlund L (2001). Energy savings in indoor swimming-pools: comparison between different heat-recovery systems. Applied Energy, 70: 281-303.
Kampel W, Aas B, Bruland A (2013). Energy-use in Norwegian swimming halls. Energy and Buildings, 59: 181-186.
Kampel W, Carlucci S, Aas B, Bruland A (2016). A proposal of energy performance indicators for a reliable benchmark of swimming facilities. Energy and Buildings, 129: 186-198.
Katsaprakakis DA (2015). Comparison of swimming pools alternative passive and active heating systems based on renewable energy sources in Southern Europe. Energy, 81: 738-753.
Kim S, Lee H, Kim H, Jang D-H, Kim H-J, Hur J, Cho Y-S, Hur K (2018). Improvement in policy and proactive interconnection procedure for renewable energy expansion in South Korea. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 98: 150-162.
Kuyumcu ME, Tutumlu H, Yumrutaş R (2016). Performance of a swimming pool heating system by utilizing waste energy rejected from an ice rink with an energy storage tank. Energy Conversion and Management, 121: 349-357.
Lam JC, Chan WW (2001). Life cycle energy cost analysis of heat pump application for hotel swimming pools. Energy Conversion and Management, 42: 1299-1306.
Lam JC, Chan WW (2003). Energy performance of air-to-water and water-to-water heat pumps in hotel applications. Energy Conversion and Management, 44: 1625-1631.
Lan S, Yang Z, Chen R, Stobart R (2018). A dynamic model for thermoelectric generator applied to vehicle waste heat recovery. Applied Energy, 210: 327-338.
Lazzarin RM, Longo GA (1996). Comparison of heat recovery systems in public indoor swimming pools. Applied Thermal Engineering, 16: 561-570.
Lee W-S, Kung C-K (2008). Optimization of heat pump system in indoor swimming pool using particle swarm algorithm. Applied Thermal Engineering, 28: 1647-1653.
Li Y, Zhang Q, Sun X, Du Y, Liao S (2015). Optimization on performance of the latent heat storage unit (LHSU) in telecommunications base stations (TBSs) in China. Energy Procedia, 75: 2119-2124.
Li Y, Du Y, Xu T, Wu H, Zhou X, Ling Z, Zhang Z (2018a). Optimization of thermal management system for Li-ion batteries using phase change material. Applied Thermal Engineering, 131: 766-778.
Li Y, Huang G, Wu H, Xu T (2018b). Feasibility study of a PCM storage tank integrated heating system for outdoor swimming pools during the winter season. Applied Thermal Engineering, 134: 490-500.
Li Y, Huang G, Xu T, Liu X, Wu H (2018c). Optimal design of PCM thermal storage tank and its application for winter available open-air swimming pool. Applied Energy, 209: 224-235.
Li Y, Huang G (2019). Development of an integrated low-carbon heating system for outdoor swimming pools for winter application. In: Proceedings of the 13th REHVA World Congress (CLIMA 2019).
DOI
Li Z, Dai J, Chen H, Lin B (2019). An ANN-based fast building energy consumption prediction method for complex architectural form at the early design stage. Building Simulation, 12: 665-681.
Li Y, Ding Z, Du Y (2020a). Techno-economic optimization of open-air swimming pool heating system with PCM storage tank for winter applications. Renewable Energy, 150: 878-890.
Li Y, Ding Z, Shakerin M, Zhang N (2020b). A multi-objective optimal design method for thermal energy storage systems with PCM: A case study for outdoor swimming pool heating application. Journal of Energy Storage, 29: 101371.
Li Y, Zhang N, Ding Z (2020c). Investigation on the energy performance of using air-source heat pump to charge PCM storage tank. Journal of Energy Storage, 28: 101270.
Li C, Li C, Lyu Y, Qiu Z (2020d). Performance of double-circulation water-flow window system as solar collector and indoor heating terminal. Building Simulation, 13: 575-584.
Limane A, Fellouah H, Galanis N (2017). Simulation of airflow with heat and mass transfer in an indoor swimming pool by OpenFOAM. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 109: 862-878.
Limane A, Fellouah H, Galanis N (2018). Three-dimensional OpenFOAM simulation to evaluate the thermal comfort of occupants, indoor air quality and heat losses inside an indoor swimming pool. Energy and Buildings, 167: 49-68.
Lu T, Lü X, Viljanen M (2014). Prediction of water evaporation rate for indoor swimming hall using neural networks. Energy and Buildings, 81: 268-280.
McKeown D (2009). Swimming Pool Operator’s Manual. Toronto: Public Health.
McMillan W (1971). Heat dispersal—Lake trawsfynydd cooling studies. In: Symposium on Freshwater Biology and Electrical Power Generation, Part I, Session 1, pp. 41-80.
MEPC (2020). Typical material used in thermal-insulation covers. Available at https://www.m-ep.co.jp/.
Mohanraj M, Belyayev Y, Jayaraj S, Kaltayev A (2018). Research and developments on solar assisted compression heat pump systems—A comprehensive review (Part A: Modeling and modifications). Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 83: 90-123.
Molineaux B, Lachal B, Guisan O (1994a). Thermal analysis of five outdoor swimming pools heated by unglazed solar collectors. Solar Energy, 53: 21-26.
Molineaux B, Lachal B, Guisan O (1994b). Thermal analysis of five unglazed solar collector systems for the heating of outdoor swimming pools. Solar Energy, 53: 27-32.
Mousia A, Dimoudi A (2015). Energy performance of open air swimming pools in Greece. Energy and Buildings, 90: 166-172.
Moya D, Aldás C, Kaparaju P (2018). Geothermal energy: Power plant technology and direct heat applications. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 94: 889-901.
OMNEXUS (2020). Typical material used in thermal-insulation covers. Available at https://omnexus.specialchem.com/.
Oró E, Allepuz R, Martorell I, Salom J (2018). Design and economic analysis of liquid cooled data centres for waste heat recovery: A case study for an indoor swimming pool. Sustainable Cities and Society, 36: 185-203.
Panaras G, Markogiannaki M, Tolis EI, Sakellaris Y, Bartzis JG (2018). Experimental and theoretical investigation of air exchange rate of an indoor aquatic center. Sustainable Cities and Society, 39: 126-134.
Panchabikesan K, Joybari MM, Haghighat F, Ramalingam V, Ding Y (2020). Feasibility study on the year-round operation of PCM based free cooling systems in tropical climatic conditions. Energy, 192: 116695.
Rajagopalan P, Jamei E (2015). Thermal comfort of multiple user groups in indoor aquatic centres. Energy and Buildings, 105: 129-138.
Rakopoulos CD, Vazeos E (1987). A model of the energy fluxes in a solar heated swimming pool and its experimental validation. Energy Conversion and Management, 27: 189-195.
Richter D (1979). Temperatur-und Wärmehaushalt des thermisch belasteten Stechlin-und Nehmitzsees Abhandlung des Meteorologischen Dienstes der DDR Nr. 123. Berlin: Akademie-Verlag.
Rohwer C (1931). Evaporation from free water surfaces. Technical Bulletins 163103. US Department of Agriculture.
Romberg TA (1995). Reform in School Mathematics and Authentic Assessment. Albany, NY, USA: State University of New York Press.
Root DE, Jr (1960). Practical aspects of solar swimming pool heating. Solar Energy, 4: 23-24.
Ruiz E, Martínez PJ (2010). Analysis of an open-air swimming pool solar heating system by using an experimentally validated TRNSYS model. Solar Energy, 84: 116-123.
Sakah M, Diawuo FA, Katzenbach R, Gyamfi S (2017). Towards a sustainable electrification in Ghana: A review of renewable energy deployment policies. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 79: 544-557.
Shah MM (2002). Evaluation of available correlations for rate of evaporation from undisturbed water pools to quiet air. HVAC&R Research, 8: 125-131.
Shah MM (2003). Prediction of evaporation from occupied indoor swimming pools. Energy and Buildings, 35: 707-713.
Shah MM (2012). Improved method for calculating evaporation from indoor water pools. Energy and Buildings, 49: 306-309.
Shah M (2014). Methods for calculation of evaporation from swimming pools and other water surfaces. ASHRAE Transactions, 120(2): 3-17.
Sharifi A, Yamagata Y (2015). Roof ponds as passive heating and cooling systems: A systematic review. Applied Energy, 160: 336-357.
Singh M, Tiwari GN, Yadav YP (1989). Solar energy utilization for heating of indoor swimming pool. Energy Conversion and Management, 29: 239-244.
Smith CC, Löf G, Jones R (1994). Measurement and analysis of evaporation from an inactive outdoor swimming pool. Solar Energy, 53: 3-7.
Somwanshi A, Tiwari AK, Sodha MS (2013). Feasibility of earth heat storage for all weather conditioning of open swimming pool water. Energy Conversion and Management, 68: 89-95.
Sun P, Wu J, Wang R, Xu Y (2011). Analysis of indoor environmental conditions and heat pump energy supply systems in indoor swimming pools. Energy and Buildings, 43: 1071-1080.
Szeicz G, McMonagle RC (1983). The heat balance of urban swimming pools. Solar Energy, 30: 247-259.
Tagliafico LA, Scarpa F, Tagliafico G, Valsuani F (2012). An approach to energy saving assessment of solar assisted heat pumps for swimming pool water heating. Energy and Buildings, 55: 833-840.
Tiwari GN, Sharma SB (1991). Design parameters for indoor swimming-pool heating using solar energy. Energy, 16: 971-975.
Tong LG, Zhang P, Yin SW, Zhang PK, Liu CP, et al. (2018). Waste heat recovery method for the air pre-purification system of an air separation unit. Applied Thermal Engineering, 143: 123-129.
Trianti-Stourna E, Spyropoulou K, Theofylaktos C, Droutsa K, Balaras CA, et al. (1998). Energy conservation strategies for sports centers: Part B. Swimming pools. Energy and Buildings, 27: 123-135.
Uribe D, Bustamante W, Vera S (2018). Potential of perforated exterior louvers to improve the comfort and energy performance of an office space in different climates. Building Simulation, 11: 695-708.
Varming (2020). Difference between passive and active applications. Available at http://www.varming.ie/blog/the-difference-between-passive-and-active-design.
Wang K, Herrando M, Pantaleo AM, Markides CN (2019). Thermoeconomic assessment of a PV/T combined heating and power system for University Sport Centre of Bari. Energy Procedia, 158: 1229-1234.
Westerlund L, Dahl J (1994). Use of an open absorption heat-pump for energy conservation in a public swimming-pool. Applied Energy, 49: 275-300.
Winterton RHS (1999). Newton’s law of cooling. Contemporary Physics, 40: 205-212.
Woolley J, Harrington C, Modera M (2011). Swimming pools as heat sinks for air conditioners: Model design and experimental validation for natural thermal behavior of the pool. Building and Environment, 46: 187-195.
Wu H, Tang R, Li Z, Zhong H (2009). A mathematical procedure to estimate solar absorptance of shallow water ponds. Energy Conversion and Management, 50: 1828-1833.
Xie H, Gong G, Fu M, Wang P, Li L (2018). A thermodynamic method to calculate energy & exergy consumption and CO2 emission of building materials based on economic indicator. Building Simulation, 11: 235-244.
Xu T, Li Y, Chen J, Liu J (2017). Preparation and thermal energy storage properties of LiNO3-KCl-NaNO3/expanded graphite composite phase change material. Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells, 169: 215-221.
Xu T, Li Y, Chen J, Wu H, Zhou X, Zhang Z (2018). Improving thermal management of electronic apparatus with paraffin (PA)/ expanded graphite (EG)/graphene (GN) composite material. Applied Thermal Engineering, 140: 13-22.
Yadav YP, Tiwari GN (1987). Analytical model of solar swimming pool: Transient approach. Energy Conversion and Management, 27: 49-54.
Yandri E (2017). The effect of Joule heating to thermal performance of hybrid PVT collector during electricity generation. Renewable Energy, 111: 344-352.
Zhao J, Bilbao JI, Spooner ED, Sproul AB (2018). Experimental study of a solar pool heating system under lower flow and low pump speed conditions. Renewable Energy, 119: 320-335.
Zsembinszki G, Farid MM, Cabeza LF (2012). Analysis of implementing phase change materials in open-air swimming pools. Solar Energy, 86: 567-577.
Publication history
Copyright
Acknowledgements
Rights and permissions

Publication history

Received: 15 January 2020
Accepted: 25 May 2020
Published: 22 August 2020
Issue date: June 2021

Copyright

© Author(s) 2020

Acknowledgements

The work described in this paper was supported by a grant from the Research Grants Council of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, China (No. 11208918). The authors appreciated the support of funding from the Department of Energy and Process Engineering of the Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Norway.

Rights and permissions

This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made.

The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder.

To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Return