Discover the SciOpen Platform and Achieve Your Research Goals with Ease.
Search articles, authors, keywords, DOl and etc.
About
Explore Content
For Authors
Alert & RSS Feed
About
Explore Content
For Authors
Alert & RSS Feed
Composite Functional Materials (CFM) is an interdisciplinary journal that caters to chemists, physicists, material scientists, engineers, and biologists, focusing on the development and application of innovative composite materials. The journal publishes peer-reviewed short communications, review articles, and full-length research papers that present cutting-edge advances in composite science and technology. Articles are supported by fundamental theoretical modeling, interface engineering, and functional approaches to composite development. The scope covers research across multiple length scales, ranging from the nanoscale to micro, meso, and full-scale product or structural levels. Emphasis is placed on composite processes aimed at high-performance applications, spanning both low-volume/high-cost and high-volume/low-cost production. This includes work that pushes the boundaries of composite materials for diverse applications, supported by advanced research in processing, performance, and functionalization.
CFM accepts submissions of original research and reviews, including those on the design, processing, structure-property relationships, performance and life-time prediction of composite materials from both fundamental and application-oriented perspectives.
The following areas of the science and engineering of materials are of particular interest:
1. Advanced Composite Materials in Aerospace
2. High-Strength and High-Conductivity Metal Alloys
3. Mineral Composite Materials for Energy and Environmental Applications
4. Intelligent Composite Materials for Optoelectronic Devices
5. Functional Composite Materials for Biological and Pharmaceutical Applications
6. Inorganic and/or Organic Composite Materials used in Catalysis
| Article type |
Requirements |
| Full length articles |
Original articles should describe original research work not previously published, and should be complete descriptions of full investigations comprising around 8000 words and with up to 20 figures and/or tables and five key words. |
| Review articles |
Review Articles should present a thorough and comprehensive overview of the chosen subject and be extensively referenced and comprise around 10000–12000 words. Authors are expected to go beyond a simple compilation of references and analyse trends, shortcomings and accomplishments in their chosen field, suggesting possible future directions of research. Illustrations with summary tables are encouraged. Flexibility of presentation is permitted, but authors are urged to arrange the subject matter clearly under general headings of Abstract, Keywords, Introduction, Main text (The heading and sub-headings of the main text are left to author's discretion), Summary and Conclusions, Future Perspectives, Acknowledgements, References be mentioned. When writing reviews authors should take proper account of all the literature, especially recent papers published over the past five years. |
| Short communication |
Short Communications/Research letters should be concise, but complete descriptions of original limited investigations comprising around 4000 words with up to 5 figures and/or tables. |
| Editorials |
Editorials are invited articles written by the journal’s editors, guest editors, or distinguished experts to provide commentary on the journal’s content, editorial policy, or significant developments within the relevant scientific fields. These pieces serve to frame important issues, highlight emerging trends, or introduce special collections. Editorials are typically concise and focused, usually ranging from 1,000 to 1,500 words. While citations may be included where appropriate, the emphasis should be on providing thought-provoking insights rather than comprehensive literature review. Editorials generally do not require abstracts and are reviewed internally by the editorial team prior to publication. |
| Highlight and comments |
Highlight and comments are short opinion-based pieces that discuss recent publications, ongoing debates, or timely issues of interest to the research community. Unlike perspectives, which take a broader view, commentaries are often narrowly focused on a specific article or event. These manuscripts are generally between 1,000 and 2,000 words and may include one or two figures or tables if essential for clarity, and 5-15 references. Abstracts are not required but may be included at the discretion of the author, usually not exceeding 100 words. Commentaries undergo editorial review, though external peer review may be employed depending on the nature of the content. |
This journal follows a double anonymized review process. Your submission will initially be assessed by our editors to determine suitability for publication in this journal. If your submission is deemed suitable, it will typically be sent to a minimum of two reviewers for an independent expert assessment of the scientific quality. The decision as to whether your article is accepted or rejected will be taken by our editors. This decision is final.
Our editors are not involved in making decisions about papers which:
• they have written themselves.
• have been written by family members or colleagues.
• relate to products or services in which they have an interest.
Any such submissions will be subject to the journal's usual procedures and peer review will be handled independently of the editor involved and their research group.
• All manuscripts are reviewed by the editorial board. Any papers which fail to meet the basic standards of the journal will be desk-rejected for reasons like out of scope, ethical conflicts, high similarities, lack of originality, flaws in research design or methods, etc. The editorial office will reassign selected papers to the Editor-in-chief.
• The Editor-in-chief will invite multiple reviewers to review the paper or assign an editorial board member to invite reviewers to review this paper.
• After at least two reviewers give their reviews and comments, the Editor-in-chief (or the assigned Editor) provides feedback to the authors, based on reviewer comments and his own review comments.
• When the author submits the revised manuscript, the assigned editor and Editor-in-chief will collaborate to make a final decision.
• For submissions from the Editor-in-Chief, Associate Editors, Guest Editor(s), other journal Board members, and authors who have conflicts of interest with them, we ensure that the paper is handled confidentially by a different team member.
• For submissions to Special Issues; if there are conflicts of interest between the Guest Editor(s) and authors, the submissions will be handled by another Editor from the Editorial Board who will manage the peer review process and make the decision whether to accept or reject the paper after peer review.
This is an open access journal: all articles will be immediately and permanently free for everyone to read and download. To provide open access, this journal has an open access fee (also known as an article publishing charge APC) which needs to be paid by the authors or on their behalf e.g. by their research funder or institution.
Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) Lets others distribute and copy the article, create extracts, abstracts, and other revised versions, adaptations or derivative works of or from an article (such as a translation), include in a collective work (such as an anthology), text or data mine the article, even for commercial purposes, as long as they credit the author(s), do not represent the author as endorsing their adaptation of the article, and do not modify the article in such a way as to damage the author's honor or reputation.
Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs (CC BY-NC-ND) For non-commercial purposes, lets others distribute and copy the article, and to include in a collective work (such as an anthology), as long as they credit the author(s) and provided they do not alter or modify the article.
As an open access journal with no subscription charges, a fee (Article Publishing Charge, APC) is payable by the authors, or their institution or funders, to cover the costs associated with publication. This ensures your article will be immediately and permanently free to access by everyone.
The APC will be covered by the publisher in the years of 2025-2027 in order to encourage contributions with highly attractive novelty and significance.
All authors must disclose any financial and personal relationships with other people or organizations that could inappropriately influence or bias their work. Examples of potential competing interests include:
• Employment
• Consultancies
• Stock ownership
• Honoraria
• Paid expert testimony
• Patent applications or registrations
• Grants or any other funding
The Declaration of Interests tool is encouraged to be completed.
Authors with no competing interests to declare should select the option, “I have nothing to declare”.
The resulting Word document containing your declaration should be uploaded at the “attach/upload files” step in the submission process. It is important that the Word document is saved in the .doc/.docx file format. Author signatures are not required.
Authors must disclose any funding sources who provided financial support for the conduct of the research and/or preparation of the article. The role of sponsors, if any, should be declared in relation to the study design, collection, analysis and interpretation of data, writing of the report and decision to submit the article for publication. If funding sources had no such involvement this should be stated in your submission.
List funding sources in this standard way to facilitate compliance to funder's requirements:
Funding: This work was supported by the National Institutes of Health [grant numbers xxxx, yyyy]; the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, Seattle, WA [grant number zzzz]; and the United States Institutes of Peace [grant number aaaa].
It is not necessary to include detailed descriptions on the program or type of grants, scholarships and awards. When funding is from a block grant or other resources available to a university, college, or other research institution, submit the name of the institute or organization that provided the funding.
If no funding has been provided for the research, it is recommended to include the following sentence:
This research did not receive any specific grant from funding agencies in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.
We accept that authors sometimes need to enhance images for clarity but any manipulation of images for the purpose of deception or fraud will be seen as scientific ethical abuse and will be dealt with accordingly.
Authors must adhere to this journal’s policy for graphical images:
• No specific feature within an image may be enhanced, obscured, moved, removed or introduced.
• Adjustments of brightness, contrast, or color balance are acceptable if, and only as long as, they do not obscure or eliminate any information present in the original image.
• Nonlinear adjustments such as changes to gamma settings must be disclosed in the figure legend.
• We do not permit the use of generative AI or AI-assisted tools to create or alter images in submitted manuscripts. Please read our policy on the use of generative AI and AI-assisted tools in figures, images and artwork, which can be found in GenAI Policies for Journals.
To verify compliance with the above, this journal may send your images to a third-party service who screen for image irregularities. Our editors may ask you to provide original data or images if any questions arise as a result of the screening. The final decision as to whether images are acceptable will be taken by our editors.
Authors are encouraged to carefully check all images before submission and to connect all the data in any figures to the original, unprocessed data.
9.1 File format
We ask you to provide editable source files for your entire submission (including figures, tables and text graphics). Some guidelines:
9.2 Double anonymized peer review
This journal follows a double anonymized review process which means author identities are concealed from reviewers and vice versa. To facilitate the double anonymized review process, we ask that you provide your title page (including author details) and anonymized manuscript (excluding author details) separately in your submission.
The title page should include:
The anonymized manuscript should contain the main body of your paper including:
It is important that your anonymized manuscript does not contain any identifying information such as author names or affiliations.
9.3 Title page
You are required to include the following details in the title page information:
9.4 Abstract
You are required to provide a concise and factual abstract which does not exceed 250 words. The abstract should briefly state the purpose of your research, principal results and major conclusions. Some guidelines:
9.5 Structured abstract
A structured abstract, by means of appropriate headings, should provide the context or background for your research. Some guidelines:
9.6 Keywords
You are required to provide 5 to 8 keywords for indexing purposes. Keywords should be written in English. Please try to avoid keywords consisting of multiple words (using "and" or "of").
We recommend that you only use abbreviations in keywords if they are firmly established in the field.
9.7 Highlights
You are encouraged to provide article highlights at submission.
Highlights are a short collection of bullet points that should capture the novel results of your research as well as any new methods used during your study. Highlights will help increase the discoverability of your article via search engines. Some guidelines:
9.8 Graphical abstract
You are required to provide a graphical abstract at submission.
The graphical abstract should summarize the contents of your article in a concise, pictorial form which is designed to capture the attention of a wide readership. A graphical abstract will help draw more attention to your online article and support readers in digesting your research. Some guidelines:
We encourage you to view example graphical abstracts and read about the benefits of including them.
9.9 Units, classifications codes and nomenclature
This journal requires you to use the international system of units (SI) which follows internationally accepted rules and conventions. If other units are mentioned within your article, you should provide the equivalent unit in SI.
Please provide up to 6 standard Inspec classification codes.
Please provide up to 6 standard JEL classification codes.
Please provide up to 6 standard MSC classification codes.
Please consult IUPAC Nomenclature of Organic Chemistry for further information.
Please consult IUBMB: Recommendations on Biochemical & Organic Nomenclature, Symbols & Terminology for further information.
Please consult IUPAC Nomenclature of Inorganic Chemistry for further information.
Please consult IUGS: Nomenclature for geological time scales and rock names for further information.
9.10 Phonetic transcription
Please adhere to IPA conventions in your choice of phonetic symbols. The Charis SIL IPA font is preferred for the presentation of IPA symbols.
9.11 Math formulae
9.12 Tables
Tables must be submitted as editable text, not as images. Some guidelines:
We recommend that you use tables sparingly, ensuring that any data presented in tables is not duplicating results described elsewhere in the article.
9.13 Figures, images and artwork
Figures, images, artwork, diagrams and other graphical media must be supplied as separate files along with the manuscript. Some excerpts:
When submitting artwork:
9.14 Artwork formats
When your artwork is finalized, "save as" or convert your electronic artwork to the formats listed below taking into account the given resolution requirements for line drawings, halftones, and line/halftone combinations:
Please do not submit:
9.15 Figure captions
All images must have a caption. A caption should consist of a brief title (not displayed on the figure itself) and a description of the image. We advise you to keep the amount of text in any image to a minimum, though any symbols and abbreviations used should be explained.
Provide captions in a separate file.
9.16 Color artwork
If you submit usable color figures with your accepted article, we will ensure that they appear in color online.
Please ensure that color images are accessible to all, including those with impaired color vision. Learn more about color and web accessibility.
For articles appearing in print, you will be sent information on costs to reproduce color in the printed version, after your accepted article has been sent to production. At this stage, please indicate if your preference is to have color only in the online version of your article or also in the printed version.
9.17 Generative AI and figures, images and artwork
Please read our policy on the use of generative AI and AI-assisted tools in figures, images and artwork, which can be found in GenAI Policies for Journals. This policy states:
9.18 Supplementary material
We encourage the use of supplementary materials such as applications, images and sound clips to enhance research. Some guidelines:
We recommend you upload research data to a suitable specialist or generalist repository.
9.19 Video
This journal accepts video material and animation sequences to support and enhance your scientific research. We encourage you to include links to video or animation files within articles. Some guidelines:
We publish all video and animation files supplied in the electronic version of your article.
9.20 Research data
We are committed to supporting the storage of, access to and discovery of research data.
Research data refers to the results of observations or experimentation that validate research findings, which may also include software, code, models, algorithms, protocols, methods and other useful materials related to the project.
Option A: Research data deposit and citation
You are encouraged to:
9.21 Data statement
To foster transparency, you are required to state the availability of any data at submission.
Ensuring data is available may be a requirement of your funding body or institution. If your data is unavailable to access or unsuitable to post, you can state the reason why (e.g., your research data includes sensitive or confidential information such as patient data) during the submission process. This statement will appear with your published article on ScienceDirect.
9.22 Data linking
Linking to the data underlying your work increases your exposure and may lead to new collaborations. It also provides readers with a better understanding of the described research.
If your research data has been made available in a data repository there are a number of ways your article can be linked directly to the dataset:
9.23 Mendeley data
This journal supports Mendeley Data, enabling you to deposit any research data (including raw and processed data, video, code, software, algorithms, protocols and methods) associated with your manuscript in a free-to-use, open access repository.
Before or during the submission process, you can deposit the relevant datasets to Mendeley Data. Please include the DOI of the deposited dataset(s) in your main manuscript file.
The datasets will be listed and directly accessible to readers next to your published article online.
9.24 Article structure
Article sections
Introduction
The introduction should clearly state the objectives of your work. We recommend that you provide an adequate background to your work but avoid writing a detailed literature overview or summary of your results.
Methods
The methods section should provide sufficient details about your materials and methods to allow your work to be reproduced by an independent researcher. Some guidelines:
Results
Results should be clear, concise and reproducible. We advise you to read the sections in this guide on supplying tables, artwork, supplementary material and sharing research data.
Discussion
The discussion section should explore the significance of your results but not repeat them. You may combine your results and discussion sections into one section, if appropriate. We recommend that you avoid the use of extensive citations and discussion of published literature in the discussion section.
Conclusion
The conclusion section should present the main conclusions of your study. You may have a stand-alone conclusions section or include your conclusions in a subsection of your discussion or results and discussion section.
Theory and calculation
The theory section should lay the foundation for further work by extending the background you provided in the introduction to your article. The calculation section should represent a practical development from a theoretical basis.
Glossary
Please provide definitions of field-specific terms used in your article, in a separate list.
Footnotes
We advise you to use footnotes sparingly. If you include footnotes in your article, ensure that they are numbered consecutively.
You may use system features that automatically build footnotes into text. Alternatively, you can indicate the position of footnotes within the text and present them in a separate section at the end of your article.
Acknowledgements
Include any individuals who provided you with help during your research, such as help with language, writing or proof reading, in the acknowledgements section. Include acknowledgements only in the title page since this journal follows a double anonymized peer review process. Do not add it as a footnote to your title.
Author contributions: CRediT
Corresponding authors are required to acknowledge co-author contributions using CRediT (Contributor Roles Taxonomy) roles:
Not all CRediT roles will apply to every manuscript and some authors may contribute through multiple roles.
Funding sources
Authors must disclose any funding sources who provided financial support for the conduct of the research and/or preparation of the article. The role of sponsors, if any, should be declared in relation to the study design, collection, analysis and interpretation of data, writing of the report and decision to submit the article for publication. If funding sources had no such involvement this should be stated in your submission.
List funding sources in this standard way to facilitate compliance to funder's requirements:
Funding: This work was supported by the National Institutes of Health [grant numbers xxxx, yyyy]; the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, Seattle, WA [grant number zzzz]; and the United States Institutes of Peace [grant number aaaa].
It is not necessary to include detailed descriptions on the program or type of grants, scholarships and awards. When funding is from a block grant or other resources available to a university, college, or other research institution, submit the name of the institute or organization that provided the funding.
If no funding has been provided for the research, it is recommended to include the following sentence:
This research did not receive any specific grant from funding agencies in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.
Appendices
We ask you to use the following format for appendices:
Vitae
Please submit a short (maximum 100 words) biography of each author. Please provide the biography in an editable format (e.g. Word, not in PDF format).
9.25 References
References within text
Any references cited within your article should also be present in your reference list and vice versa. Some guidelines:
Linking to cited sources will increase the discoverability of your research.
Before submission, check that all data provided in your reference list are correct, including any references which have been copied. Providing correct reference data allows us to link to abstracting and indexing services such as Scopus, Crossref and PubMed. Any incorrect surnames, journal or book titles, publication years or pagination within your references may prevent link creation.
We encourage the use of Digital Object Identifiers (DOIs) as reference links as they provide a permanent link to the electronic article referenced. See the example below, though be aware that the format of such citations should be adapted to follow the style of other references in your paper.
DOI link example (for an article not yet in an issue):
[1] Loc Tan Nguyen, Stephan Maes, Filip E. Du Prez. Enabling the reprocessability and debonding of epoxy thermosets using dynamic poly(β-amino amide) curing agents. Advanced Functional Materials 2024, In Press. https://doi.org/10.1002/adfm.202419240.
[2] Yutong Ding, Hongxin Guo, Mi Ouyang, Ge Meng, Feng Chen, Tairong Kuang. Humidity-resistant wearable triboelectric nanogenerator utilizing a bound-water-rich zwitterionic hydrogel with microphase-separated domains. Advanced Functional Materials 2024, In Press. https://doi.org/10.1002/adfm.202421164.
Reference style
Indicate references by adding a number within square brackets in the text. You can refer to author names within your text, but you must always give the reference number, e.g., "as demonstrated [3,6]. Barnaby and Jones [8] obtained a different result ....".
Number references in the order they appear in your article.
Examples:
Reference to a journal publication:
[1] Tetsuya Kambe, Reina Hosono, Shotaro Imaoka, Akiyoshi Kuzume, Kimihisa Yamamoto. Solution phase mass synthesis of 2D atomic layer with hexagonal boron network. Journal of the American Chemical Society 2019, 141, 12984-12988. https://doi.org/10.1021/jacs.9b06110.
[2] Jing Zou, Jing Wu, Yizhou Wang, Fengxia Deng, Jizhou Jiang, Yizhou Zhang, Song Liu, Neng Li, Han Zhang, Jiaguo Yu, Tianyou Zhai and Husam N. Alshareef. Alshareef. Additive-mediated intercalation and surface modification of MXenes. Chemical Society Reviews 2022, 51, 2972-2990. https://doi.org/10.1039/D0CS01487G.
Reference to a journal publication with an article number:
[3] G. Krishnamurthy Grandhi, David Hardy, Mokurala Krishnaiah, Brenda Vargas, Basheer Al-Anesi, Mahesh P. Suryawanshi, Diego Solis-Ibarra, Feng Gao, Robert L. Z. Hoye, Paola Vivo. Wide-bandgap perovskite-inspired materials: Defect-driven challenges for high-performance optoelectronics. Advanced Functional Materials 2024, 34, 2307441. https://doi.org/10.1002/adfm.202307441.
[4] Roujia Chen, Chu Lun Alex Leung, Chun Huang. Exploring the properties of disordered rocksalt battery cathode materials by advanced characterization. Advanced Functional Materials 2024, 34, 2308165. https://doi.org/10.1002/adfm.202308165.
Reference to a book:
[5] William Strunk Jr., E. B. White, Test Editor, Roger Angell. The Elements of Style, fourth ed., Longman, New York, 2000.
Reference to a chapter in a book:
[6] G.R. Mettam, L.B. Adams, in: B.S. Jones, R.Z. Smith (Eds.), Introduction to the Electronic Age, E-Publishing, Inc. New York, 2023, pp. 281–304.
Reference to a website:
[7] Cancer Research UK, Cancer statistics reports for the UK. http://www.cancerresearchuk.org/aboutcancer/statistics/cancerstatsreport/, 2023 (accessed 13 March 2023).
Reference to a dataset:
[8] M. Oguro, S. Imahiro, S. Saito, T. Nakashizuka, Mortality data for Japanese oak wilt disease and surrounding forest compositions [dataset], Mendeley Data, v1, 2015. https://doi.org/10.17632/xwj98nb39r.
Reference to software:
[9] E. Coon, M. Berndt, A. Jan, D. Svyatsky, A. Atchley, E. Kikinzon, D. Harp, G. Manzini, E. Shelef, K. Lipnikov, R. Garimella, C. Xu, D. Moulton, S. Karra, S. Painter, E. Jafarov, S. Molins, Advanced Terrestrial Simulator (ATS) v0.88 [software], Zenodo, March 25, 2020. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.3727209.
Web references
When listing web references, as a minimum you should provide the full URL and the date when the reference was last accessed. Additional information (e.g. DOI, author names, dates or reference to a source publication) should also be provided, if known.
You can list web references separately under a new heading directly after your reference list or include them in your reference list.
Data references
We encourage you to cite underlying or relevant datasets within article text and to list data references in the reference list.
When citing data references, you should include:
Add [dataset] immediately before your reference. This will help us to properly identify the dataset. The [dataset] identifier will not appear in your published article.
Software references
Cite software (including computational code, scripts, models, notebooks and libraries) in the same way as other sources of information to support proper attribution and credit, reproducibility, collaboration and reuse, and encourage building on the work of others to further research. To facilitate this, useful information is provided.
A reference to software should include the following elements:
If an article exists that describes the software, it should be cited as an additional reference, as well as citing the software itself. Do not cite the article instead of the software.
Preprint references
We ask you to mark preprints clearly. You should include the word "preprint" or the name of the preprint server as part of your reference and provide the preprint DOI.
Where a preprint has subsequently become available as a peer-reviewed publication, use the formal publication as your reference.
If there are preprints that are central to your work or that cover crucial developments in the topic, but they are not yet formally published, you may reference the preprint.
Reference management software
If you use a citation plug-in from these products, select the relevant journal template and all your citations and bibliographies will automatically be formatted in the journal style. We advise you to remove all field codes before submitting your manuscript to any reference management software product.
If a template is not available for this journal, follow the format given in examples in the reference style section of this Guide for Authors.
10.1 Submission checklist
Before completing the submission of your manuscript, we advise you to read our submission checklist:
10.2 Suggest reviewers
To support the peer review process, we ask you to provide names and institutional email addresses of several potential reviewers for their manuscript. Some guidelines:
The journal editors will take the final decision on whether to invite your suggested reviewers.
11.1 Copyright
Authors will be asked to complete a publishing agreement after acceptance. The corresponding author will receive a link to the online agreement by email.
11.2 Permission for copyrighted works
If excerpts from other copyrighted works are included in your article, you must obtain written permission from the copyright owners and credit the source(s) within your article.
11.3 Proof correction
To ensure a fast publication process we will ask you to provide proof corrections within two days.
Corresponding authors will be sent an email which includes a link to our online proofing system, allowing annotation and correction of proofs online. The environment is similar to Word. You can edit text, comment on figures and tables and answer questions raised by our copy editor. Our web-based proofing service ensures a faster and less error-prone process.
You can choose to annotate and upload your edits on the PDF version of your article, if preferred. We will provide you with proofing instructions and available alternative proofing methods in our email.
The purpose of the proof is to check the typesetting, editing, completeness and correctness of your article text, tables and figures. Significant changes to your article at the proofing stage will only be considered with approval of the journal editor.
11.4 DOI link
A Digital Object Identifier (DOI) link to the published version of your open access article on ScienceDirect will be sent by email to the corresponding author. You can share the DOI link via email and within your social networks.
11.5 Responsible sharing
We encourage you to share and promote your article to give additional visibility to your work, enabling your paper to contribute to scientific progress and foster the exchange of scientific developments within your field.
11.6 Post-publication amendments
Errata and Corrigenda
We will publish a correction of your article if a significant error is discovered after publication. An Erratum will be published if we introduced the error; a Corrigendum if the author introduced the error.
Retractions
Articles may be withdrawn, retracted, removed or replaced after publication if they contain substantial errors that cannot be corrected by publishing an Erratum or a Corrigendum, or if ethical violations come to light after publication.