AI Chat Paper
Note: Please note that the following content is generated by AMiner AI. SciOpen does not take any responsibility related to this content.
{{lang === 'zh_CN' ? '文章概述' : 'Summary'}}
{{lang === 'en_US' ? '中' : 'Eng'}}
Chat more with AI
PDF (1.3 MB)
Collect
Submit Manuscript AI Chat Paper
Show Outline
Outline
Show full outline
Hide outline
Outline
Show full outline
Hide outline
Research Article | Publishing Language: Chinese

Policy Responsiveness from a Bureaucratic Perspective: A List Experiment Targeting Grassroots Civil Servants

Yao LIU1, Xiao HAN2( ), Chenhui LIU1
School of Public Policy and Administration, Xi'an Jiaotong University
School of Public Administration, University of Electronic Science and Technology of China
Show Author Information

Abstract

Street-level bureaucrats' policy voice behavior connects public demands with policymaking, yet existing theories of policy responsiveness fail to explain this prevalent phenomenon. Traditional responsiveness research primarily examines the opinion-policy nexus between citizens and politicians, overlooking the role of the bureaucracy. Information experiences attenuation during bottom-up transmission within hierarchical organizations. The efficacy of information flow from frontline levels fundamentally determines the operational efficacy of the entire governance system. Although lacking formal authority to initiate or revise policies, street-level bureaucrats serve as frontline responsive agents. Their voice behavior functions as a bridge translating “public discourse” into “policy language,” mitigating information asymmetry in policymaking.

This study conceptualizes street-level bureaucratic policy responsiveness as the tendency to incorporate public opinion into policy recommendations. A list experiment involving 3501 street-level bureaucrats revealed that nearly half incorporate public opinion in their policy advice, demonstrating policy responsiveness. This conceptualization enriches policy responsiveness theory by adding the “policy voicer” role to the bureaucratic framework, expanding responsive actors beyond politicians, senior officials, or holistic governments to include street-level bureaucrats. Furthermore, this study examines how top-down leadership pressure and bottom-up public complaint pressure within China's pressure-based governance system affect street-level bureaucratic policy responsiveness. Bayesian multivariate probit modeling indicates leadership pressure exerts significantly positive effects, whereas public complaint pressure only enhances responsiveness when leadership pressure is diminished. It suggests bureaucratic pressure constitutes the core driver of street-level policy responsiveness.

This study reveals a dual relationship between public opinion and bureaucracy under pressure-based governance, manifesting as both alignment and tension. On the one hand, the responsiveness pathway reflects alignment. Public opinion provides essential information for higher-level governments to understand grassroots governance realities, thereby gaining leadership attention. Moreover, tiered governmental systems demonstrate both institutional requirements and consensus for responding to public opinion. On the other hand, the competing influences of top-down versus bottom-up pressures reveal tension. The pressure-based governance system enables superior governments to effectively reorient subordinate agencies' attention allocation through administrative pressure. However, once public opinion enters the bureaucratic system, responsiveness becomes subject to jurisdictional accountability pressures. This institutional arrangement risks reinforcing frontline responsiveness to mechanistic top-down compliance rather than substantive engagement with public opinion itself. When these pressures compete for bureaucratic prioritization, bottom-up public pressure demonstrably occupies a disadvantaged position.

References

【1】
【1】
 
 
China Public Administration Review
Pages 154-176

{{item.num}}

Comments on this article

Go to comment

< Back to all reports

Review Status: {{reviewData.commendedNum}} Commended , {{reviewData.revisionRequiredNum}} Revision Required , {{reviewData.notCommendedNum}} Not Commended Under Peer Review

Review Comment

Close
Close
Cite this article:
LIU Y, HAN X, LIU C. Policy Responsiveness from a Bureaucratic Perspective: A List Experiment Targeting Grassroots Civil Servants. China Public Administration Review, 2026, 8(3): 154-176. https://doi.org/10.26599/CPAR.2026.9680308

11

Views

0

Downloads

0

Crossref

Published: 17 November 2026
© 2026 Tsinghua University Press