@article{ZHANG2026, 
author = {Ying ZHANG and Yang ZHOU and Jiuzhen ZHANG},
title = {Editorial Talent Evaluation in China: Practices during the 14th Five-Year Plan Period and Mechanism Optimization for the 15th Five-Year Plan Period},
year = {2026},
journal = {Science-Technology & Publication},
volume = {45},
number = {9},
pages = {89-95},
keywords = {14th Five-Year Plan period, 15th Five-Year Plan period, publishing editors, talent evaluation, mechanism optimization},
url = {https://www.sciopen.com/article/10.16510/j.cnki.kjycb.2026.09.019},
doi = {10.16510/j.cnki.kjycb.2026.09.019},
abstract = {Technological change and the publishing industry’s continuing pursuit of high-quality development are reshaping the competencies required of editors. It is therefore necessary to review the progress and limitations of editorial talent evaluation during the 14th Five-Year Plan period and to consider how evaluation can better support both editors’ professional development and the construction of a capable publishing workforce. Evaluation is treated here not merely as an administrative judgment at the end of a cycle, but as a mechanism that can influence professional learning, occupational mobility, organizational priorities, and the allocation of development opportunities. This study examines evaluation practices against the objectives of emphasizing innovation capability, quality, effectiveness, contribution, knowledge, and technology, and uses the findings to propose mechanism improvements for the 15th Five-Year Plan period (2026–2030). The empirical investigation combined a targeted questionnaire with follow-up expert interviews. The questionnaire covered four areas: basic information about publishing units, the current state of editorial talent evaluation, practical problems, and suggestions for improvement. It was distributed to 39 publishing units, and 32 valid responses were collected. After the questionnaire data had been analyzed, industry experts were invited to participate in in-depth interviews. This design enabled the study to compare formal evaluation arrangements with practitioners’ assessments of how those arrangements operate and where further adjustment is required, while also connecting quantitative patterns with explanations from day-to-day publishing practice across different organizations. The results show that evaluation during the 14th Five-Year Plan period increasingly emphasized editors’ work quality, practical effectiveness, and contribution. Evaluation organizers and reviewers became more diverse, evaluation cycles were set with a degree of flexibility, and evaluation outcomes received some recognition and played a positive role. Nevertheless, the goals of evaluation still require adjustment; occupational categories remain insufficiently differentiated; indicators for digital competencies are limited; evaluation methods lack adequate standardization and intelligent support; and feedback on results is not sufficiently clear. These shortcomings constrain the ability of evaluation to guide professional growth and respond to the changing division of labor in publishing. For the 15th Five-Year Plan period, the study proposes five improvements aligned with the publishing sector’s development priorities. First, evaluation should adopt a people-centered objective and explicitly support editors’ personal growth and career development. Second, a differentiated mechanism should be built on refined occupational classification, including areas such as ancient-book collation, integrated publishing, international publishing, and copyright operations. Third, the indicator system should be reviewed regularly and updated with input from frontline editors and relevant experts. Fourth, an operational framework should define the responsibilities of participating actors and clarify the auxiliary role and boundaries of intelligent technologies in expert evaluation. Fifth, a standardized feedback process should be established together with accessible channels for appeal and review. These measures can make editorial talent evaluation more precise, transparent, adaptive, and development-oriented.}
}