@article{YUAN2026, 
author = {Haowei YUAN and Yun SHI},
title = {Editorial Review Boundaries in Science and Technology Journals and Collaborative Governance of Research Misconduct},
year = {2026},
journal = {Science-Technology & Publication},
volume = {45},
number = {9},
pages = {115-121},
keywords = {science and technology journals, editorial review boundaries, research misconduct, research integrity, collaborative governance},
url = {https://www.sciopen.com/article/10.16510/j.cnki.kjycb.2026.09.007},
doi = {10.16510/j.cnki.kjycb.2026.09.007},
abstract = {With the continuous improvement of the research integrity governance system, standards for full-process review in academic publishing have been steadily elevated, and specialist in-depth review tasks such as tracing research back to its source, image forensic analysis, and raw data verification have been increasingly extended to science and technology journals. Meanwhile, research misconduct has become industrialized and technology-driven. In 2025, Springer Nature used AI tools to identify 25 000 problematic papers from over 1.5 million; STM reported in September 2025 that its Integrity Hub screened more than 125 000 papers monthly and intercepted about 1 000 suspected paper mill submissions. Traditional review models based on editors' personal experience are increasingly inadequate. While science and technology journals bear the responsibility as gatekeepers, their review authority and responsibility have become overly generalized in practice. Frontline editors are passively burdened with extensive investigative tasks that exceed their job authority and competence. A survey of science and technology journal practitioners in Chongqing showed that 65.7% of journals lacked methodological review and 61.3% were lax in verifying research authenticity; 69.9% of editors' time was spent on proofreading, with only 32.3% on content planning. Another survey in Henan Province found that 74.36% of frontline editors reported high or moderately high work pressure. These have led to role overreach, excessive workload, and rising compliance risks. This paper systematically distinguishes between two types of review: basic compliance review and specialist in-depth review. Basic compliance review refers to routine checks that editors can perform using submitted materials and standard tools, including plagiarism detection, reference verification, ethics approval review, and authorship verification. Specialist in-depth review involves investigative tasks requiring special qualifications and legal authority, such as verifying original experimental records, tracing instrument data, and detecting deep image manipulation. A three-dimensional framework based on authority, resource capacity, and compliance risk is proposed to delineate these boundaries. The paper then analyzes the manifestations and underlying causes of the expansion of review responsibilities. Manifestations include a structural shift in editors' work focus, chronic overload and burnout, mismatched professional competence, accumulating compliance risks, and the absence of third-party agencies. Underlying causes involve over-concentration of governance pressure on the publishing end, industry perceptions that insist on journals' all-encompassing responsibility, lack of clear institutional norms since journals are not statutory investigation bodies, and the absence of specialized third-party agencies. To address these issues, this paper proposes a multi-stakeholder co-governance system comprising precise review by science and technology journals, tracing research back to its source by research institutions as primary responsible entities, and professional support by third-party agencies. It clarifies the necessity and functional positioning of third-party agencies, including the organizations that could establish them such as industry associations, national research institutions, and certified market entities, their core functions such as technical verification, compliance investigation, expert arbitration, and standard setting, and their operational mechanisms. International practices offer examples for considering how specialist support can complement editorial work. The proposed framework aims to help science and technology journals clarify review boundaries, reduce unnecessary burdens on editors, and improve collaborative mechanisms for addressing research misconduct.}
}