AI Chat Paper
Note: Please note that the following content is generated by AMiner AI. SciOpen does not take any responsibility related to this content.
{{lang === 'zh_CN' ? '文章概述' : 'Summary'}}
{{lang === 'en_US' ? '中' : 'Eng'}}
Chat more with AI
Article Link
Submit Manuscript
Show Outline
Show full outline
Hide outline
Show full outline
Hide outline
Review Article

Review on direct contact condensation of vapor bubbles in a subcooled liquid

Jiguo TangLicheng Sun( )Hongli LiuHongtao Liu( )Zhengyu Mo
State Key Laboratory of Hydraulics and Mountain River Engineering, College of Water Resource & Hydropower, Sichuan University, Chengdu, China
Show Author Information


Condensation of vapor bubbles in a subcooled liquid is known to influence heat transfer and pressure oscillation in subcooled boiling and direct contact condensation. This study reviews the published literature concerning interfacial heat transfer and bubble dynamics in the process of bubble condensation. The correlations for bubble condensation are analyzed and evaluated with a database covering a wide range of Reynolds, Jacob, and Prandtl numbers. Then, the investigations addressing bubble dynamics are reviewed, which focus on the bubble condensation patterns, motion, collapse, and the pressure oscillations induced by bubble condensation, as well as the effect of noncondensable gas and field. Despite the extensive experiments of bubble condensation available in the literature, it is shown that there is still a shortage of investigation focused on the variation of thermal boundary layer and turbulence formed near the bubble at the micro-scale, which could help to develop the prediction method of bubble condensation in the future. The transportation of noncondensable gas inside the mixture bubble and effect of capillary waves formed on the bubble surface on the actual vapor-liquid contact area and thermal boundary are also suggested to be further investigated to gain the thorough understanding of the bubble condensation process.


Akiyama, M. 1973. Bubble collapse in subcooled boiling. Bull JSME, 16:570-575.
Al Issa, S., Macián-Juan, R. 2017. CFD validation of new Nu-Re correlations for the condensation of large steam bubbles directly injected into a flow in a vertical pipe and effects of bubbles forces upon momentum transfer. Int J Multiphase Flow, 94:173-188.
Al Issa, S., Weisensee, P., Macián-Juan, R. 2014. Experimental investigation of steam bubble condensation in vertical large diameter geometry under atmospheric pressure and different flow conditions. Int J Heat Mass Tran, 70:918-929.
Beard, K. V., Pruppacher, H. R. 1969. A determination of the terminal velocity and drag of small water drops by means of a wind tunnel. J Atmos Sci, 26:1066-1072.
Boziuk, T. R., Smith, M. K., Glezer, A. 2019a. Acoustic enhancement of direct-contact condensation using capillary waves. Int J Heat Mass Tran, 138:357-372.
Boziuk, T. R., Smith, M. K., Glezer, A. 2019b. Enhanced two-phase heat transfer by direct-contact condensation using directional acoustic actuation. In: Proceedings of the 25th International Workshop on Thermal Investigations of ICs and Systems, 1-6.
Brucker, G. G., Sparrow, E. M. 1977. Direct contact condensation of steam bubbles in water at high pressure. Int J Heat Mass Tran, 20:371-381.
Butler, C., Cid, E., Billet, A. M. 2016. Modelling of mass transfer in Taylor flow: Investigation with the PLIF-I technique. Chem Eng Res Des, 115:292-302.
Cao, Y., Kawara, Z., Yokomine, T., Kunugi, T. 2016a. Experimental and numerical study on nucleate bubble deformation in subcooled flow boiling. Int J Multiphase Flow, 82:93-105.
Cao, Y., Kawara, Z., Yokomine, T., Kunugi, T. 2016b. Visualization study on bubble dynamical behavior in subcooled flow boiling under various subcooling degree and flowrates. Int J Heat Mass Tran, 93:839-852.
Chen, Y. M., Mayinger, F. 1992. Measurement of heat transfer at phase interface of condensing bubble. Int J Multiphase Flow, 18:877-890.
Cho, S., Chun, S. Y., Baek, W. P., Kim, Y. 2004. Effect of multiple holes on the performance of sparger during direct contact condensation of steam. Exp Therm Fluid Sci, 28:629-638.
Dahikar, S. K., Sathe, M. J., Joshi, J. B. 2010. Investigation of flow and temperature patterns in direct contact condensation using PIV, PLIF and CFD. Chem Eng Sci, 65:4606-4620.
Datta, P., Chakravarty, A., Ghosh, K., Mukhopadhyay, A., Sen, S. 2017. Modeling aspects of vapor bubble condensation in subcooled liquid using the VOF approach. Numer Heat Tr A: Appl, 72:236-254.
Douglas, Z. W., Boziuk, T. R., Smith, M. K., Glezer, A. 2012. Acoustically enhanced boiling heat transfer. Phys Fluids, 24:052105.
Faraday, M. 1831. On the forms and states assumed by fluids in contact with vibrating elastic surfaces. Philos Trans R Soc Lond, 121:299-340.
Florschuetz, L. W., Chao, B. T. 1965. On the mechanics of vapor bubble collapse. J Heat Transf, 87:209-220.
Francois, J., Dietrich, N., Guiraud, P., Cockx, A. 2011. Direct measurement of mass transfer around a single bubble by micro-PLIFI. Chem Eng Sci, 66:3328-3338.
Fukuda, S. 1982. Pressure variations due to vapor condensation in liquid, (II) phenomena at large vapor mass flow flux. Journal of the Atomic Energy Society of Japan, 24:466-474.
Gallego-Marcos, I., Kudinov, P., Villanueva, W., Puustinen, M., Räsänen, A., Tielinen, K., Kotro, E. 2019. Effective momentum induced by steam condensation in the oscillatory bubble regime. Nucl Eng Des, 350:259-274.
Hao, Y., Prosperetti, A. 2000. The collapse of vapor bubbles in a spatially non-uniform flow. Int J Heat Mass Tran, 43:3539-3550.
Hattori, Y., Ueno, I. 2009. Microbubble formation in abrupt condensation of vapor bubble exposed to subcooled pool. In: Proceedings of the ASME 2009 2nd Micro/Nanoscale Heat and Mass Transfer International Conference, Paper No. MNHMT2009-18371, 691-695.
Higeta, K., Mori, Y. H., Komotori, K. 1979. Condensation of a single vapor bubble rising in another immiscible liquid. AIChE Symp Ser, 75:256-265.
Hoffmann, A., Schleicher, E., Keller, L., Alonso, J. L., Pitz-Paal, R. 2018. Application of a single wire-mesh sensor in a parabolic trough facility with direct steam generation. Sol Energy, 159:1016-1030.
Hong, S. J., Park, G. C., Cho, S., Song, C. H. 2012. Condensation dynamics of submerged steam jet in subcooled water. Int J Multiphase Flow, 39:66-77.
Hu, Y., Wang, H., Song, M., Huang, J. 2019. Marangoni effect on microbubbles emission boiling generation during pool boiling of self-rewetting fluid. Int J Heat Mass Tran, 134:10-16.
Hughmark, G. A. 1967. Mass and heat transfer from rigid spheres. AIChE J, 13:1219-1221.
Inaba, N., Watanabe, N., Aritomi, M. 2013. Interfacial heat transfer of condensation bubble with consideration of bubble number distribution in subcooled flow boiling. J Therm Sci Tech, 8:74-90.
Inada, S., Miyasaka, Y., Sakumoto, S., Izumi, R. 1981. A study on boiling curves in subcooled pool boiling (2nd report, an effect of contamination of surface on boiling heat transfer and collapse vapor slug). Trans JSME, 47:2021-2029.
Isenberg, J., Sideman, S. 1970. Direct contact heat transfer with change of phase: Bubble condensation in immiscible liquid. Int J Heat Mass Tran, 13:997-1011.
Jain, D. S., Rao, S. S., Srivastava, A. 2016. Rainbow schlieren deflectometry technique for nanofluid-based heat transfer measurements under natural convection regime. Int J Heat Mass Tran, 98:697-711.
Jeon, S. S., Kim, S. J., Park, G. C. 2011. Numerical study of condensing bubble in subcooled boiling flow using volume of fluid model. Chem Eng Sci, 66:5899-5909.
Jo, B., Erkan, N., Okamoto, K. 2020. Richardson number criteria for direct-contact-condensation-induced thermal stratification using visualization. Prog Nucl Energy, 118:103095.
Jo, H., Jo, D. 2017. Experimental studies of condensing vapor bubbles in subcooled pool water using visual and acoustic analysis methods. Ann Nucl Energy, 110:171-185.
Kalman, H. 2003. Condensation of bubbles in miscible liquids. Int J Heat Mass Tran, 46:3451-3463.
Kalman, H., Mori, Y. H. 2002. Experimental analysis of a single vapor bubble condensing in subcooled liquid. Chem Eng J, 85:197-206.
Kalman, H., Ullmann, A. 1999. Experimental analysis of bubble shapes during condensation in miscible and immiscible liquids. J Fluid Eng, 121:496-502.
Kandlikar, S. G. 2017. Enhanced macroconvection mechanism with separate liquid-vapor pathways to improve pool boiling performance. J Heat Transfer, 139:051501.
Khosravifar, P., Zonouzi, S. A., Aminfar, H., Mohammadpourfard, M. 2021. Numerical investigation of the condensation of a rising bubble inside a subcooled liquid under magnetic field. Int J Therm Sci, 160:106674.
Kim, S., Park, G. 2011. Interfacial heat transfer of condensing bubble in subcooled boiling flow at low pressure. Int J Heat Mass Tran, 54:2962-2974.
Kumagai, S., Kawabata, K., Yoshikawa, H., Shimada, R. 2000. Pressure fluctuation associated with bubble motion in microbubble emission boiling from a vertical surface. JSME Int J B: Fluid T, 43:206-212.
Leighton, T. G., Walton, A. J. 1987. An experimental study of the sound emitted from gas bubbles in a liquid. Eur J Phys, 8:98-104.
Lerner, Y., Kalman, H., Letan, R. 1987. Condensation of an accelerating- decelerating bubble: Experimental and phenomenological analysis. J Heat Transfer, 109:509-517.
Lerner, Y., Letan, R. 1990. Dynamics of condensing bubbles at intermediate frequencies of injection. J Heat Transfer, 112:825-829.
Li, S. Q., Wang, P., Lu, T. 2015. Numerical simulation of direct contact condensation of subsonic steam injected in a water pool using VOF method and LES turbulence model. Prog Nucl Energy, 78:201-215.
Li, W., Meng, Z., Sun, Z., Fan, G., Wang, J. 2020a. Investigation on steam direct contact condensation injected vertically at low mass flux, part II: Steam-air mixture experiment. Int J Heat Mass Tran, 155:119807.
Li, W., Wang, J., Zhou, Y., Sun, Z., Meng, Z. 2019. Investigation on steam contact condensation injected vertically at low mass flux: Part I pure steam experiment. Int J Heat Mass Tran, 131:301-312.
Li, X., Tang, J. G., Sun, L. C., Li, J., Bao, J. J., Liu, H. L. 2020b. Enhancement of subcooled boiling in confined space using ultrasonic waves. Chem Eng Sci, 223:115751.
Liu, H. L, Tang, J. G., Sun, L. C., Mo, Z. Y., Xie, G. 2020. An assessment and analysis of phase change models for the simulation of vapor bubble condensation. Int J Heat Mass Tran, 157:119924.
Lucic, A., Emans, M., Mayinger, F., Zenger, C. 2004. Interferometric and numerical study of the temperature field in the boundary layer and heat transfer in subcooled flow boiling. Int J Heat Fluid Flow, 25:180-195.
Lucic, A., Mayinger, F. 2010. Transport phenomena in subcooled flow boiling. Heat Mass Transf, 46:1159-1166.
Magnaudet, J., Legendre, D. 1998. The viscous drag force on a spherical bubble with a time-dependent radius. Phys Fluids, 10:550-554.
Mazed, D., Frano, R. L., Aquaro, D., del Serra, D., Sekachev, I., Olcese, M. 2018. Experimental investigation of steam condensation in water tank at sub-atmospheric pressure. Nucl Eng Des, 335:241-254.
Moalem, D., Sideman, S., Orell, A., Hetsroni, G. 1973. Direct contact heat transfer with change of phase: Condensation of a bubble train. Int J Heat Mass Tran, 16:2305-2319.
Moore, D. W. 1965. The velocity of rise of distorted gas bubbles in a liquid of small viscosity. J Fluid Mech, 23:749-766.
Narayan, S., Singh, T., Singh, S., Srivastava, A. 2019. Experiments on the effects of varying subcooled conditions on the dynamics of single vapor bubble and heat transfer rates in nucleate pool boiling regime. Int J Heat Mass Tran, 134:85-100.
Nebuchinov, A. S., Lozhkin, Y. A., Bilsky, A. V., Markovich, D. M. 2017. Combination of PIV and PLIF methods to study convective heat transfer in an impinging jet. Exp Therm Fluid Sci, 80:139-146.
Nguyen, T. T., Tsuzuki, N., Murakawa, H., Duong, N. H., Kikura, H. 2016. Measurement of the condensation rate of vapor bubbles rising upward in subcooled water by using two ultrasonic frequencies. Int J Heat Mass Tran, 99:159-169.
Pan, L., Tan, Z., Chen, D., Xue, L. 2012. Numerical investigation of vapor bubble condensation characteristics of subcooled flow boiling in vertical rectangular channel. Nucl Eng Des, 248:126-136.
Plesset, M. S. 1966. A discussion on deformation of solids by the impact of liquids, and its relation to rain damage in aircraft and missiles, to blade erosion in steam turbines, and to cavitation erosion - Shockwaves from cavity collapse. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series A, Mathematical and Physical Sciences, 110:241-244.
Prosperetti, A. 2017. Vapor bubbles. Annu Rev Fluid Mech, 49:221-248.
Prosperetti, A., Hao, Y. 2002. Vapor bubbles in flow and acoustic fields. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 974:328-347.
Qiu, B., Yang, Q., Meng, F, Zhang, D., Chong, D., Liu, J., Yan, J. 2020. Experimental investigation on the interface shape of bubble condensation for vertical upward steam jet at low mass flux. Int J Heat Mass Tran, 157:119909.
Qu, X. H., Tian, M. C., Zhang, G. M., Leng, X. L. 2015. Experimental and numerical investigations on the air-steam mixture bubble condensation characteristics in stagnant cool water. Nucl Eng Des, 285:188-196.
Ranz, W., Marshall, W. 1952. Evaporation from drops. Chem Eng Prog, 48:141-146.
Schulz, J. M., Junne, H., Böhm, L., Kraume, M. 2020. Measuring local heat transfer by application of Rainbow Schlieren Deflectometry in case of different symmetric conditions. Exp Therm Fluid Sci, 110:109887.
Simpson, M. E., Chan, C. K. 1982. Hydrodynamics of a subsonic vapor jet in subcooled liquid. J Heat Transfer, 104:271-278.
Sinha, G. K., Mahimkar, S., Srivastava, A. 2019. Schlieren-based simultaneous mapping of bubble dynamics and temperature gradients in nucleate flow boiling regime: Effect of flow rates and degree of subcooling. Exp Therm Fluid Sci, 104:238-257.
Soedarmo, A. A., Rodrigues, H. T., Pereyra, E., Sarica, C. 2019. A new objective and distribution-based method to characterize pseudo- slug flow from wire-mesh-sensors (WMS) data. Exp Therm Fluid Sci, 109:109855.
Song, S., Yue, X., Zhao, Q., Chong, D., Chen, W., Yan, J. 2020. Numerical study on mechanism of condensation oscillation of unstable steam jet. Chem Eng Sci, 211:115303.
Suzuki, K., Kokubu, T., Nakano, M., Kawamura, H., Ueno, I., Shida, H., Ogawa, O. 2005. Enhancement of heat transfer in subcooled flow boiling with microbubble emission. Exp Therm Fluid Sci, 29:827-832.
Suzuki, K., Yuki, K., Hong, C. 2011. Subcooled boiling with microbubble emission (on mechanism of MEB generation). In: Proceedings of the 22nd International Symposium on Transport Phenomena.
Takeda, Y. 1986. Velocity profile measurement by ultrasound Doppler shift method. Int J Heat Fluid Flow, 7:313-318.
Tang, J. G., Sun, L. C., Du, M., Liu, H. T., Mo, Z. Y., Bao, J. J. 2019a. Experimental investigation of transition process from nucleate boiling to microbubble emission boiling under transient heating modes. AIChE J, 65:e16555.
Tang, J. G., Sun, L. C., Wu, D., Du, M., Xie, G., Yang, K. 2019b. Effects of ultrasound on subcooled pool boiling on a small plain heating surface. Chem Eng Sci, 201:274-287.
Tang, J. G., Xie, G., Bao, J. J., Mo, Z. Y., Liu, H. T., Du, M. 2018. Experimental study of sound emission in subcooled pool boiling on a small heating surface. Chem Eng Sci, 188:179-191.
Tang, J., Yan, C., Sun, L. 2015a. A study visualizing the collapse of vapor bubbles in a subcooled pool. Int J Heat Mass Tran, 88:597-608.
Tang, J., Yan, C., Sun, L. 2015b. Feature of acoustic sound signals involved in vapor bubble condensation and its application in identification of condensation regimes. Chem Eng Sci, 137:384-397.
Tang, J., Yan, C., Sun, L. 2015c. Effects of noncondensable gas and ultrasonic vibration on vapor bubble condensing and collapsing. Exp Therm Fluid Sci, 61:210-220.
Tang, J., Yan, C., Sun, L. 2016. Enhanced vapor bubble condensation and collapse with ultrasonic vibration. Exp Therm Fluid Sci, 70:115-124.
Tang, J., Yan, C., Sun, L., Li, Y., Wang K. Y. 2015d. Effect of liquid subcooling on acoustic characteristics during the condensation process of vapor bubbles in a subcooled pool. Nucl Eng Des, 293:492-502.
Tange, M., Takagi, S., Watanabe, M., Shoji, M. 2004. Microbubble emission boiling in a microchannel and minichannel. Therm Sci Eng, 12:23-29.
Tompkins, C., Prasser, H. M., Corradini, M. 2018. Wire-mesh sensors: A review of methods and uncertainty in multiphase flows relative to other measurement techniques. Nucl Eng Des, 337:205-220.
Ueno, I., Ando, J., Koiwa, Y., Saiki, T., Kaneko, T. 2015. Interfacial instability of a condensing vapor bubble in a subcooled liquid. Eur Phys J Spec Top, 224:415-424.
Ueno, I., Saiki, T., Osawa, T., Hong, C. 2013. Condensation and collapse of vapor bubble injected to subcooled pool. In: Proceedings of the 11th International Conference on Nanochannels, Microchannels, and Minichannels, Paper No. ICNMM2013-73190, V001T04A011.
Ullmann, A., Letan, R. 1989. Effect of noncondensibles on condensation and evaporation of bubbles. J Heat Transfer, 111:1060-1067.
Ünal, H. C. 1976. Maximum bubble diameter, maximum bubble- growth time and bubble growth rate during the subcooled nucleate flow boiling of water up to 17.7 MN/m2. Int J Heat Mass Tran, 19:643-649.
Wanchoo, R. K., Sharma, S. K., Raina, G. K. 1997. Drag coefficient and velocity of rise of a single collapsing two-phase bubble. AIChE J, 43:1955-1963.
Warrier, G. R., Vijay, N. B., Dhir, K. 2002. Interfacial heat transfer during subcooled flow boiling. Int J Heat Mass Tran, 45:3947-3959.
Xu, Q., Ye, S., Liu, W., Chen, Y., Chen, Q., Guo, L. 2019. Intelligent identification of steam jet condensation regime in water pipe flow system by wavelet multiresolution analysis of pressure oscillation and artificial neural network. Appl Therm Eng, 147:1047-1058.
Yang, B., Prosperetti, A. 2008. Vapour bubble collapse in isothermal and non-isothermal liquids. J Fluid Mech, 601:253-279.
Yang, Q., Qiu, B., Chen, W., Chong, D., Liu, J., Yan, J. 2020. Experimental investigation on the condensation regime and pressure oscillation characteristics of vertical upward steam jet condensation with low mass flux. Exp Therm Fluid Sci, 111:109983.
Yang, S. R., Seo, J., Hassan, Y. A. 2019. Thermal hydraulic characteristics of unstable bubbling of direct contact condensation of steam in subcooled water. Int J Heat Mass Tran, 138:580-596.
Yeoh, G. H. 2019. Thermal hydraulic considerations of nuclear reactor systems: Past, present and future challenges. Exp Comput Multiphase Flow, 1:3-27
Yoo, J., Estrada-Perez, C. E., Hassan, Y. A. 2018. Development of a mechanistic model for sliding bubbles growth prediction in subcooled boiling flow. Appl Therm Eng, 138:657-667.
Yuan, D. W., Pan, L. M., Chen, D. Q., Wang, X. J. 2009. Condensation heat transfer coefficient at vapour-liquid interface of subcooled flow boiling in vertical narrow rectangular channel. Nucl Power Eng, 30:30-34 (in Chinese).
Zeitoun, O., Shoukri, M., Chatoorgoon, V. 1995. Interfacial heat transfer between steam bubbles and subcooled water in vertical upward flow. Int J Multiphase Flow, 117:402-407.
Zeng, Q., Cai, J., Yin, H., Yang, X., Watanabe, T. 2015. Numerical simulation of single bubble condensation in subcooled flow using Open FOAM. Prog Nucl Eng, 83:336-346.
Zhang, Y., Feng, L., Liu, L., Fu, X., Lu, D., Yang, Y., Ouyang, B. 2019. Experimental research on heat transfer characteristics of the unstable multi-hole steam jets and development of the lumped condensation model. Int J Heat Mass Tran, 139:46-57.
Zhao, Q., Hibiki, T. 2018. Review: Condensation regime maps of steam submerged jet condensation. Prog Nucl Energy, 107:31-47.
Experimental and Computational Multiphase Flow
Pages 91-112
Cite this article:
Tang J, Sun L, Liu H, et al. Review on direct contact condensation of vapor bubbles in a subcooled liquid. Experimental and Computational Multiphase Flow, 2022, 4(2): 91-112.






Web of Science




Received: 02 September 2020
Revised: 28 October 2020
Accepted: 15 November 2020
Published: 08 January 2021
© Tsinghua University Press 2020